How to build something to vacuum and convey concrete powder

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the challenges of vacuuming and conveying concrete powder using compressed air or a blower. Participants explore various methods and equipment options for moving approximately 50 tons of material over a vertical distance of 8-10 feet and a horizontal distance of up to 20 feet.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes their initial attempts using a 2" PVC compression fitting and expresses a desire to scale up to 3" or 4" systems.
  • Another participant suggests using an industrial-strength Shop Vac, questioning its effectiveness with longer hoses.
  • A different participant warns that motors may not last long with concrete dust and mentions the existence of purpose-built equipment for such tasks.
  • One suggestion involves using a cyclonic separator to prevent dust from damaging the vacuum pump.
  • Another participant notes that vacuum conveyors are commonly used in industry for bulk material transport and emphasizes that creating a working model is complex.
  • There is a proposal to separate the air pump from the transport system using eductors.
  • One participant discusses the feasibility of bagging the material instead, suggesting that using industrial bags could simplify the process.
  • Another participant counters that handling 100-pound bags in confined spaces could be problematic, advocating for the use of garden bags for easier handling.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express a range of ideas and suggestions, but no consensus is reached on the best method to vacuum and convey the concrete powder. Multiple competing views remain regarding equipment choices and methods of handling the material.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention limitations regarding the durability of motors with concrete dust and the complexity of creating a homemade solution. There are also unresolved considerations about the efficiency and practicality of various proposed methods.

latemodel18
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Need to move some concrete powder, would like to use compressed air or a blower. I will need it to vacuum and convey the product, the storage vessel is broken and there is no way to gravity or manually feed it. The vertical distance is 8-10' and no more then 20' horizontal. I have played around on a small scale with a 2" pvc compression fitting drilled and fitted with my air inlet and a smaller pipe on the inside drilled with angle holes in it and it seems to move oil dry pretty good as long as I keep the suction side short.I have had no luck with anything bigger. I would like to use 3" or 4". Can anyone help with ideas on what would work and what size blower or compressor would be needed to accomplish this. Have access to a pretty good size blower or will rent a big compressor. About 50 tons of material to move. Thanks in advance for any help that may be offered.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
latemodel18 said:
Need to move some concrete powder, would like to use compressed air or a blower. I will need it to vacuum and convey the product, the storage vessel is broken and there is no way to gravity or manually feed it. The vertical distance is 8-10' and no more then 20' horizontal. I have played around on a small scale with a 2" pvc compression fitting drilled and fitted with my air inlet and a smaller pipe on the inside drilled with angle holes in it and it seems to move oil dry pretty good as long as I keep the suction side short.I have had no luck with anything bigger. I would like to use 3" or 4". Can anyone help with ideas on what would work and what size blower or compressor would be needed to accomplish this. Have access to a pretty good size blower or will rent a big compressor. About 50 tons of material to move. Thanks in advance for any help that may be offered.

What about a Shop Vac? Would that work with longer hoses? You could use an industrial strength version if needed...
 
From what I am told, the motors do not last long with the concrete dust and it might take awhile for 50 tons. I am sure they sell purpose built equipment for this, just trying to build something since the customer already owns a 50hp blower. Thanks for the reply
 
Vacuum conveyors are used quite extensively in industr for transport of bulk materials.
Trying to hand make a working model isn't just an overnight task.

Your system would eventually be similar to this, perhaps not on that scale depending on vacuum pipe size.
http://christianson.com/brands/augervac/
The pipe coming out the right hand side is the vacuum hose.

I am not sure a centrifugal blower has the oomph to develop the pressures andair flow needed for you task.
http://www.polimak.com/Roots_Blower_Pneumatic.htm
shows a positive displacement blower/compressor.

If instead , you bag the material , 50 tons is about 1000 bags at 100pds bag.
There are industrial bags that hold a ton, give or take, that you move can move around by the attached straps. Hooking and lifting with a front end loader or forklift would work.
Just shovel the cement into the bag and your done in a day, or two.
 
Separate the air pump from the transport system with an eductor or eductors.

I enjoy the daydream of designing an air powered household vacuum using eductors and jets in place of the brush roll.
 
you'd need about 2000 bags at 50lbs a bag handling 100lb bags in a confined uneven space would be problematic. the idea of using the garden bags like the ones for masons sand sounds much better get two guys with shovels filling those and use a crane to haul it out probably take two days to do and costs about $1800 Can/US to do depending on labor cost of the guys shoveling and the crane length.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 15 ·
Replies
15
Views
4K