How to Calculate Heat Generated on R2 After Finding Voltage and Charge?

  • Thread starter Thread starter aang
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Charge Voltage
AI Thread Summary
To calculate the heat generated on resistor R2 after finding the voltage and charge, one must first understand the conservation of charge during the redistribution process. Initially, all charge (8 Coulombs) is on capacitor C2 before S2 is closed. After S2 is closed, the charges redistribute, with Q2 being 16/3 Coulombs on C2 and Q3 being 8/3 Coulombs on C3. The heat generated can be calculated using the formula for power (P = I^2R) and integrating over time to find the total energy dissipated as heat. Understanding the voltage across R2 after the redistribution is crucial for accurate calculations.
aang
Messages
29
Reaction score
3
Homework Statement
c1=c3=2,c2=4.switch s1 is closed while s2 is open. A long time after s2 is closed and s1 is opened.

A long time after S2 IS CLOSED,

Find the charge in c3.

The sum of energy stored in c2 and c3.

Heat generated in R2.
Relevant Equations
V=IR,Q=CV,W=1/2CV2
I WAS ABLE TO FIND THE voltage in c1 ,c2 which are 4,2.THE CHARGES ARE THE SAME(8).
I DONOT KNOW HOW TO CONTINUE.
Screenshot 2021-05-30 112348.png
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
Physics news on Phys.org
Hello again,

Please help me understand the problem statement (by rendering it completely ?). So far I have the scenario
  • all capacitors are uncharged. s1 and s2 are open
  • s1 is closed -- this charges C1 and C2
  • s1 is opened
  • s2 is closed -- this redistributes the charge from C2 over C2 and C3
Did I get it correctly ?

Also, how can you get numerical results (4,2 things of what ? Charge 8 of what?)

##\ ##
 
yeah. you got it correct.
Things of what in the sense if you are referring to the units v and c.(I don't know what you are asking.
)
 
First of all you got to mention the units (as @BvU said) of capacitance ,voltage and charges. Are they 2 and 4 Farads respectively and 4V (Volts) and 2 V respectively and 8 Coulomb charge each?

Second , to answer what happens after S2 is closed (and S1 opened) you have to use conservation of charge and equality of voltages. Long time after S2 is closed, there is no current through the resistor ##R_2##, hence by applying KVL we get that $$V_2=V_3\iff \frac{Q_2}{C_2}=\frac{Q_3}{C_3}$$.

What do you get if you apply conservation of charge for the moment before S2 is closed (S1 opened) at which all the charge ##Q## is inside ##C_2## and for the final moment which is long time after S2 is closed and the initial charge ##Q## of ##C_2## has been redistributed in ##Q_2## (final charge on ##C_2## ) and ##Q_3## (final charge on ##C_3##)?
 
I NEED MORE INFORMATION ABOUT how to apply conservation of charge.
units YOU mention are correct.
 
aang said:
I NEED MORE INFORMATION ABOUT how to apply conservation of charge.
Well, in order to apply any conservation principle one has to discriminate between two moments in time: (##t_1## and ##t_2##) and then equate the conserved quantity (which here is the charge) as ##charge (t_1)=charge (t_2)##
Here in this problem we have:
  • time ##t_1##: BEFORE S2 is closed the charge Q=8Coulomb is all in ##C_2##
  • time ##t_2##:long time AFTER S2 is closed we have charge ##Q_2## in ##C_2## and ##Q_3## in ##C_3##
what conservation of charge tell us for the relation between ##Q##, ##Q_2## and ##Q_3##
 
Sorry I edited my post #6, it was not completely correct.
 
Q3=8/3c
Q2=16/3c
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
aang said:
Q3=8/3c
Q2=16/3c

Yes I think that is correct
 
  • #10
I GOT IT.
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
  • #11
How will you calculate the heat generated on ##R_2##?
 
Back
Top