How to integral ? How can they ignore that variable?

9 replies · 2K views · last reply
Outrageous
Messages
373
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


I don't understand case 1. In case 2 that is normal integration , isn't?
Then why case 1 can simply ignore the r ? I don't think r is constant.


Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution


Please guide. Thanks
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This way? No sure is that correct .
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten derivation on grid paper, rotated: Case 1 gives m(2ṙθ̇ + rθ̈) = 0 with ṙ = dr/dt, θ̇ = dθ/dt, θ̈ = d²θ/dt²; then (1/r)d/dt(r²θ̇) = 2ṙθ̇ + rθ̈; so m (1/r) d/dt(r²θ̇) = 0, giving r²θ̇ = J, constant (equation 1). Case 2: (1/r) dr/dt = 0, leading to ∫(1/r)dr = ∫0 dt and [ln r] from a to b = 0.
    image.jpg
    44.4 KB · Views: 438
Sorry, I don't really know how to use it.
 
Attachments
  • Handwritten notes on grid paper: Case 1 gives m(2 r-dot theta-dot + r theta-double-dot) = 0, leading to r squared theta-dot = l (constant), labelled (1). Case 2 integrates (1/r) dr/dt = 0 as the integral of r^-1 dr equals the integral of 0 dt, giving [ln r] from a to b = l.
    image.jpg
    49.5 KB · Views: 444
Outrageous said:

Homework Statement


I don't understand case 1. In case 2 that is normal integration , isn't?
Then why case 1 can simply ignore the r ? I don't think r is constant.

Are you talking about the equation$$
\frac m r \frac{d(r^2\dot \theta)}{dt}=0$$giving ##r^2\dot \theta=l##? If so, they didn't ignore the ##\frac m r##. They multiplied both sides by its reciprocal before integrating.
 
I'm not quite sure what you mean. Nobody said r was constant. But the fact that [itex]\frac{d}{dt}(r^2\theta') = 0[/itex] does imply that [itex]r^2\theta' = C[/itex] is constant (why?).
 
(1/r)(dr/dt)= 0 , (dr/dt)= 0
∫ dr = ∫ 0 dt
The answer should be r = constant.
Isn't ?
Can the answer be ∫(1/r)dr= ∫dt .
Then ln(r/ro)= t. Integral from ro to r , and integral from 0 to t. ro is original value r.
 
I thought you said you were puzzled about 1, not 2.


Outrageous said:
(1/r)(dr/dt)= 0 , (dr/dt)= 0
∫ dr = ∫ 0 dt
The answer should be r = constant.
Isn't ?

Yes, that's right.

Can the answer be ∫(1/r)dr= ∫dt .
Then ln(r/ro)= t. Integral from ro to r , and integral from 0 to t. ro is original value r.

##\int \frac 1 r\, dr = \int 0\, dt##, not ##\int 1\, dt##.