How to perform a metacentric height lab experiment

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

This discussion revolves around conducting a metacentric height lab experiment, focusing on the practical aspects of setting up the experiment, measuring the center of gravity (CG), and understanding the calculations involved. Participants share their experiences, challenges, and suggestions related to the experiment's execution and theoretical underpinnings.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses confusion about the lab report and the lack of available apparatus at their university, seeking guidance on fabricating the necessary equipment.
  • Another participant outlines the basic requirements for the experiment, including the need for a floating box, measuring scales, and a tank for water, while suggesting that specific questions would yield better advice.
  • Several participants discuss the measurement of the center of gravity using a knife edge support, with questions raised about alternative methods if such equipment is unavailable.
  • There is a reiteration of the experiment's purpose, which is to determine the CG of the floating box by measuring the heel produced by shifting weights, with references to the relationship between heel angle and metacentric height.
  • One participant shares their successful experience with a flat-bottomed pontoon and expresses a desire to experiment with differently shaped pontoons, seeking resources for understanding metacentric height calculations for complex shapes.
  • Another participant suggests that stability characteristics are covered in naval architecture texts and provides a link to a guide on stability calculations for sailboats, encouraging further inquiry into the topic.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the fundamental aspects of the experiment and the importance of measuring the center of gravity, but there is no consensus on the best methods for measurement or the specifics of conducting the experiment with various pontoon shapes. Multiple competing views and uncertainties remain regarding the practical execution of the experiment.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention limitations related to the availability of specific apparatus and the need for alternative methods to measure the center of gravity. There are also unresolved questions about the calculations involved for different pontoon shapes and the application of theoretical principles to practical experiments.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for students and educators in engineering or naval architecture, particularly those interested in experimental methods for determining metacentric height and stability characteristics of floating bodies.

PrincessIceFall
Messages
49
Reaction score
0
I need help in understanding how to conduct this experiment. I found this lab report online but it is confusing

https://www.google.ae/#q=metacentric+height+experiment

http://site.iugaza.edu.ps/mymousa/files/Experiment-2hydraulics-lab-.pdf

I am finding it difficult to visualize the experiment. Also, I asked my university lab technician and he said that our university does not even have the apparatus. But he said I can actually fabricate the apparatus by myself, but I am not even sure how to do that. Please if anyone has any clue about this experiment than please tell me about it.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
The basic experiment requires that you have a floating box of known dimensions. The outside of the box should either have a scale attached to it of some means to measure the draft of the box when it is floating. The scales should be attached to all four corners of the box.

You will also need to fabricate a box which is deep enough so that it floats without filling with water when it is heeled to one side when carrying a set of inclining weights and a mast and pendulum for measuring the angle of heel when the inclining weights are shifted to one side. Additional weights may be required to trim the box to obtain level drafts before the inclining weights are moved to one side.

You will also need to have a tank large enough which can be filled with water so that the box can float and heel from side to side without coming into contact with the sides of this tank.

This video shows a basic setup with a description of how to take the measurements of the vessel and other data:



There are other videos of similar experiments posted on YouTube.

It's hard to advise you about this experiment in a general fashion. It would be better if you ask specific questions. As always, read the experimental procedures and try to understand them.
 
how are they measuring the center of gravity? I know they use the knife edge support, but like I still don't get how they are measuring it. Also, if my university does not have a knife edge support then how would I measure the COG? Is there any other way?
 
Samiha Samin said:
how are they measuring the center of gravity? I know they use the knife edge support, but like I still don't get how they are measuring it. Also, if my university does not have a knife edge support then how would I measure the COG? Is there any other way?

That's the purpose of this experiment. It's to determine the location of the CG of the floating box by measuring the change in heel of the box as a known weight is shifted from side to side. The height of the metacenter above the bottom of the box is based on the geometry of the box itself; the unknown height of the CG can be determined by knowing the relationship between the amount of heel produced by a known transverse moment.
 
SteamKing said:
That's the purpose of this experiment. It's to determine the location of the CG of the floating box by measuring the change in heel of the box as a known weight is shifted from side to side. The height of the metacenter above the bottom of the box is based on the geometry of the box itself; the unknown height of the CG can be determined by knowing the relationship between the amount of heel produced by a known transverse moment.
If I am not mistaken. The distance of the center of gravity from the base of the pontoon is one of the parameters needed to calculate the metacentric height. If you read step 2 of the procedure in the lab report, it says to weigh the pontoon and to measure the CG by using the knife edge support.
 
Samiha Samin said:
If I am not mistaken. The distance of the center of gravity from the base of the pontoon is one of the parameters needed to calculate the metacentric height. If you read step 2 of the procedure in the lab report, it says to weigh the pontoon and to measure the CG by using the knife edge support.

The location of M above B is determined by the waterplane characteristics of the pontoon and the volume of displacement. Similarly, the location of B above the keel (bottom) of the pontoon can be determined from the shape of the submerged portion of the pontoon. After all, the weight of the pontoon is equal to the weight of water displaced when the pontoon is floating.

In a regular inclining experiment as performed on a real ship, the location of G is unknown. You cannot take an ocean liner or aircraft carrier out of the water and balance it on a knife edge in order to find its center of gravity.

By shifting the movable weights back and forth to heel the pontoon, you can plot the heeling moment of the pontoon against the tangent of the heel angle. If you have done the experiment correctly, a straight line should be obtained. Knowing the amount of heel produced by the moment of the shifting weights, the GM of the pontoon can be calculated. Having determined the location of M, one can work back geometrically and find the location of G.

According to the dimensions of the pontoon given in the procedure, the expected location of G will be somewhere within the hull of the pontoon, so your knife edge will require special construction to support the pontoon and mast by sticking into the hull a ways.
 
SteamKing said:
The location of M above B is determined by the waterplane characteristics of the pontoon and the volume of displacement. Similarly, the location of B above the keel (bottom) of the pontoon can be determined from the shape of the submerged portion of the pontoon. After all, the weight of the pontoon is equal to the weight of water displaced when the pontoon is floating.

In a regular inclining experiment as performed on a real ship, the location of G is unknown. You cannot take an ocean liner or aircraft carrier out of the water and balance it on a knife edge in order to find its center of gravity.

By shifting the movable weights back and forth to heel the pontoon, you can plot the heeling moment of the pontoon against the tangent of the heel angle. If you have done the experiment correctly, a straight line should be obtained. Knowing the amount of heel produced by the moment of the shifting weights, the GM of the pontoon can be calculated. Having determined the location of M, one can work back geometrically and find the location of G.

According to the dimensions of the pontoon given in the procedure, the expected location of G will be somewhere within the hull of the pontoon, so your knife edge will require special construction to support the pontoon and mast by sticking into the hull a ways.

Hi, I haven't posted here in a long time. I just want to give an update that I have since my last post successfully done an experiment on a flat bottomed pontoon of known dimensions and have also done the calculations to obtain a set of reading and coded them into matlab. However, the challenge now is that I want to perform and experiment and do calculations on a pontoon that is differently shaped. My aim is to perform experiments with different shaped pontoons until I can work my way up to a pontoon that very closely depicts a real boat/ship. So right now, I want to do an experiment on a pontoon that may not be flat bottomed. And this is proving to be difficult. I wanted to ask if you know of any kind of books that may help in the understanding of calculating the metacentric height of a more complex shaped model? Or do you have any advice on how to carry out such an experiment or calculation? Thank you
 
Yes. The calculation of the stability characteristics of a vessel is covered in many texts on naval architecture.

The attached guide illustrates some of the stability calculations for a sailboat:

http://www.sailboatwayra.com/Pdf/Hydrostatic and Stability.pdf

These techniques can be generally applied to almost any vessel with a single hull. Take some time to review it, and then come back with any questions you have about the things you don't understand. Pay close attention to calculating the volume of displacement and the transverse moment of inertia of the waterplane.

Good Luck! :)
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 29 ·
Replies
29
Views
7K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K