How to talk about interpretations

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter tzimie
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Interpretations
62 replies · 8K views · last reply
bhobba said:
On the surface that is contradictory - I think you need to expand on it..

Between any two pure states of QM a continuous transformation can always be found.
Assuming the initial pure state (1,0) corresponds to clicks on channel A of an SG filter and the final state (0,1) corresponds to clicks on channel B of the same filter, a continuous transformation of state (1,0) into state (0,1) through a continuous family of intermediate states formalised into complex vectors implies that at some point the association between intermediate states and the respective channels A and B will change. This change in the correspondence between components of the state vector and the channels enabling their manifestation as "clicks" of the detectors cannot be continuous.
 
Sugdub said:
Assuming the initial pure state (1,0) corresponds to clicks on channel A of an SG filter and the final state (0,1) corresponds to clicks on channel B of the same filter, a continuous transformation of state (1,0) into state (0,1) through a continuous family of intermediate states formalised into complex vectors implies that at some point the association between intermediate states and the respective channels A and B will change. This change in the correspondence between components of the state vector and the channels enabling their manifestation as "clicks" of the detectors cannot be continuous.

That's incorrect.

A continuous transformation exists between such states, as it does between any two states.

A little linear algebra easily shows this.

Thanks
Bill