I HUP for spin seems violated: 0 x sy > sz/2...?

  • I
  • Thread starter Thread starter JBlue
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Hup Spin
JBlue
Messages
2
Reaction score
1
TL;DR Summary
After measuring Sx, we know its state exactly. This seems to violate Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle (HUP).
HUP for spins reads
$$\langle\sigma_z^2\rangle\langle\sigma_x^2\rangle \ge \frac{1}{4}|\langle\sigma_y\rangle|^2$$
Right after measuring ##\sigma_z##, we know it exactly, and so ##\langle\sigma_z^2\rangle=0##.
However, HUP then implies that ##\langle\sigma_y^2\rangle=\infty##

Even if we say that the uncertainty isn't ##0## but some small ##\epsilon##, we still get a ##\langle\sigma_y^2\rangle## that is very large, though it shouldn't be greater than ##\hbar##.

What am I missing?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hmm, considering a state ##|z^+\rangle##, I get the following quantities

##\sigma_x=1##
##\sigma_z=0##
##\sigma_x\sigma_z = 0##
##\frac{1}{2}|\langle\left[S_x,S_z\right]\rangle| = 0##
##\therefore \sigma_x\sigma_z \geq \frac{1}{2}|\langle\left[S_x,S_z\right]\rangle| = 0##

[edit] - So this is the the Robertson uncertainty relation. I also tested it for the schroedinger uncertainty relation and I also get ##0\geq0##
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes JBlue and topsquark
JBlue said:
TL;DR Summary: After measuring Sx, we know its state exactly. This seems to violate Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle (HUP).

HUP for spins reads
$$\langle\sigma_z^2\rangle\langle\sigma_x^2\rangle \ge \frac{1}{4}|\langle\sigma_y\rangle|^2$$
Right after measuring ##\sigma_z##, we know it exactly, and so ##\langle\sigma_z^2\rangle=0##.
However, HUP then implies that ##\langle\sigma_y^2\rangle=\infty##

Even if we say that the uncertainty isn't ##0## but some small ##\epsilon##, we still get a ##\langle\sigma_y^2\rangle## that is very large, though it shouldn't be greater than ##\hbar##.

What am I missing?
Let's see. You prepared the system in an eigenstate of ##s_x##, say in the eigenstate with ##\sigma_x=\hbar/2##. In the usual ##\hat{s}_z## eigenbasis, ##|\pm 1/2 \rangle##, it's
$$|\sigma_x=\hbar/2 \rangle=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(|1/2 \rangle +|-1/2 \rangle).$$
This gives
$$\langle \sigma_z \rangle=\langle \sigma_x =1/2|\hat{s}_z|\sigma_x=1/2 \rangle=0,$$
and
$$\langle \sigma_z^2 \rangle = \langle \sigma_x =1/2|\hat{s}_z^2|\sigma_x=1/2 \rangle=\hbar^2/4,$$
i.e.,
$$\Delta \sigma_z=\hbar/2.$$
In the same way you also get
$$\Delta \sigma_y=\hbar/2.$$
The HUP states that
$$\delta \sigma_y \Delta \sigma_z \geq \frac{\hbar}{2} |\langle (-\mathrm{i}) [\hat{s}_y,\hat{s}_z] \rangle|.$$
Now ##[\hat{s}_y,\hat{s}_z]=\mathrm{i} \hat{s}_x##. The expectation value on the right-hand side of our HUP thus is ##\hbar/2## and thus the right-hand side gives ##\hbar^2/4##, i.e., the HUP is valid with the equality sign.

If you want to apply the HUP to ##s_x## and ##s_z## you get ##0## on the left-hand side of the HUP, because you prepared an eigenstate of ##s_x## and thus ##\Delta s_z=0##. Then the HUP is of course always fulfilled. Of course it's not ##\langle s_z^2 \rangle## you have to use on the lefthand side of the HUP but the standard deviation, ##\Delta s_z##, which is defined as
$$\Delta s_z^2=\langle s_z^2 \rangle-\langle s_z \rangle^2.$$
 
  • Like
Likes JBlue and topsquark
Thanks, vanhees71, for walking through the example.
I had a silly confusion that is now perfectly cleared up!
 
Insights auto threads is broken atm, so I'm manually creating these for new Insight articles. Towards the end of the first lecture for the Qiskit Global Summer School 2025, Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, Olivia Lanes (Global Lead, Content and Education IBM) stated... Source: https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/quantum-entanglement-is-a-kinematic-fact-not-a-dynamical-effect/ by @RUTA
If we release an electron around a positively charged sphere, the initial state of electron is a linear combination of Hydrogen-like states. According to quantum mechanics, evolution of time would not change this initial state because the potential is time independent. However, classically we expect the electron to collide with the sphere. So, it seems that the quantum and classics predict different behaviours!
Back
Top