Imperfections in magnet pole pieces

In summary, the conversation is about designing a permanent magnet for low-field NMR experiments on a tight budget. The magnet has a small saw cut in the edge and the speaker is wondering how this will affect the homogeneity. They plan on shimming the magnets and have tried modeling the effect, but need a quantitative assessment. The desired homogeneity is 1 ppm or better. A photo of the purchased discs is requested to better understand the situation.
  • #1
TL;DR Summary
I'm designing a gap magnet for NMR experiments, and the steel pole pieces I have obtained has a 5 mm deep 1mm wide saw cut into the peripherie. Will that be catastrophic for field homogeneity?
Hi all, I'm fairly new here.

I'm currently designing an as-homogene-as-possible permanent magnet for low-field NMR and similar experiments. I'm on a fairly tight budget, and having finally found pole pieces for my magnets, I got them even though they have a small saw cut in the edge. approx. 5 mm from the peripherie towards the center, all the way through. Both magnets and pole pieces are cylindrical disks, 10 cm in diameter, magnets are 15mm thick and pole pieces are 5.

Asuming that i can get the pole pieces parallel and polished to a mirror finnish, how bad would you estimate these cuts would mess up my homogeneity? I plan on having a way of shimming the magnets regardless.

I've tried modelling the effect in FEMM (free magnet finite element software), and it looks negligible towards the center of the magnet, but obviously looking at field lines on an image isn't really quantitative. Please see attached.

Thanks for the interest!

--Chris
 

Attachments

  • flawed pole.jpg
    flawed pole.jpg
    62.3 KB · Views: 213
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
In general you want homogeneity of 1 ppm or better through your sample volume to resolve individual lines. It can be worse if you just want to say "I got a signal out of the sample."

I can't picture your description. Can you attach a photo?
 
  • #3
Thanks for your reply! I'm hoping to get crude structural analysis resolution, so ppm level is likely needed.

Sorry for the poor description, here's a link to the discs I purchased:https://www.ebay.com/itm/102mm-x-5mm-Round-Disc-Circle-Mild-Steel-Sheet-Plate-Size-/264306833910?

I guess you wouldn't expect homogeneity right on the edge of pole pieces anyway, but I'm having trouble visualising the magnitude of the influence of the defect.
 

Suggested for: Imperfections in magnet pole pieces

Replies
9
Views
610
Replies
18
Views
1K
Replies
21
Views
457
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
987
Replies
2
Views
1K
Back
Top