Ionic or covalent in tetrahydroxoaluminate ion?

  1. Consider the metal-ligand complex of the tetrahydroxoaluminate ion. [tex][Al(OH)_{4}]^-[/tex]

    In this ion, the aluminium is bonded with four hydroxides where each hydroxide is a ligand.

    My question:
    Is the aluminium-hydroxide bond ionic or covalent?

    I can think of the ionic one working in someway like this:

    [tex]Al^{+3} + 4(OH)^- \rightarrow [Al(OH)_{4}]^- [/tex]


    I can also think of it as being covalent:

    [tex]Al + 3(OH) + (OH)^- \rightarrow [Al(OH)_{4}]^- [/tex]

    Which would be more "correct"?
    Aluminium is a metal, so you would expect it to form ionic bonds right? But I heard of instances where metals form covalent bonds, especially in metal complexes. So I hope I can clear this confusion in my head somehow. Also, will a complete octet be formed in both cases?

    Thanks!

    BiP
     
  2. jcsd
  3. I would go for covalent bonding it seems more appropriate, Hydroxide ions do posses a lone pair of electrons. Hence they can provide both the electrons to form a dative covalent bond.

    Metal complexes do commonly form covalent bonds, especially transition metals. the metal complex will form a tetrahedral structure in this case hydroxide ions act as ligands...

    http://www.see.murdoch.edu.au/info/student/chemtutorials/equations.html

    click on the link and look for equations 27-29
     
Know someone interested in this topic? Share a link to this question via email, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Have something to add?