The discussion centers on the effectiveness and acceptability of collective punishment in schools, highlighting its prevalence and impact on students. Participants overwhelmingly criticize collective punishment as an ineffective disciplinary tool that fosters resentment among students and undermines personal responsibility. A specific case is presented where a 12-year-old student faced collective punishment for the actions of her peers, leading to a well-articulated essay arguing against the practice, referencing Article 33 of the 4th Geneva Convention. The consensus is that collective punishment is unfair and counterproductive, often harming the teacher-student relationship.
PREREQUISITESEducators, school administrators, parents of school-aged children, and policymakers interested in effective disciplinary practices and student rights in educational environments.
Newai said:The penalty for necroposting is a temporary ban on all PFers.
I think that was tried before but apparently some people liked it too much, which led to too many forum-wide bans.lisab said:Whew, I thought we were all going to be paddled.