Is it possible to find the tension force without mass?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around finding the tension force in a system with two identical masses connected by a rope, where specific coefficients of friction are provided but no mass values are given. Participants express frustration over the inability to determine the tension without knowing the mass, despite successfully calculating acceleration. The conversation highlights that while gravitational acceleration and friction coefficients are known, these alone do not yield a numerical value for tension. It is emphasized that a definite value for tension cannot be achieved without mass information. The discussion concludes with a request for clarification on the units of various quantities involved in the problem.
Nerdydude101
Messages
54
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


The system to the right has two identical masses. (one is hanging off the ledge of a table, one is on the table, they are connected by a rope.) tge coefficients of kinetic and static friction are .54 and .63 respectively. Find the acceleration and the tension in the rope. (No masses are given, just that they are equal, and we ignore the mass of the rope and friction of the pully.[/B]

Homework Equations


I found the acceleration no problem, however the tension force eludes me and my teacher. (I should note that this isn't my homework, it was from another school and someone from there showed it to me. Me and my teacher were very confused and have spent days trying to figure it out.). Is there any way to find the tension force without the need for mass? If there is any way, even beyond what we would have learned by now in AP Physics then please tell me, but if there is a way to do it using just forces and kinematics then even better. Thanks![/B]

The Attempt at a Solution


We've tried breaking down ewuations and everything to find a solution without mass but have not come up with anything.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Is it possible to construct any quantity with the units of a force using your input variables?
 
The only things that are given are the masses are equal, and the friction forces. You also know the gravitational acceleration but that doesn't get s numerical answer, all we could get was F=9.8m but I want a numerical value for the tension force
 
Yes, that is all you will be able to do. What I am trying to explain is how you can see that it is impossible to get a definite value without knowing the mass.

So what are the units of the following quantities?
The friction coefficients
The gravitational acceleration
The ratio between the masses
The tension in the string
 
That's what I had been asking, if it was possible to find it. The coefficients of friction are static = .63 and the kinetic = .54, the gravitational acceleration is 9.8m/s^2, ratio between the masses js 1:1, and the tension on the rope is what I have been asking about.
 
Yes, but what I am asking is whether or not you know which units those quantities are measured in, e.g., acceleration as you say is measured in m/s^2.
 
Can you show the picture of the system?
 
Back
Top