Is my approach for pascal's law wrong?

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Dileep Ramisetty
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
In hydraulic lift utilising pascal law, larger piston area is A1 and the smaller piston area is A2
mass in = mass out and volume in = volume out (in-compressible),so
A1*x1=A2*x2 (let x1 and x2 are displacements of respective pistons)
A1*V1 =A2*V2 (on differentiation gives continuity eq)
A1 * acceleration1=A2*acceleration2 (on differentiating again)
as mass flow rates m are equal,
m*A1*acceleration1=m*A2*acceleration2
A1*F1=A2*F2 (is giving me inverse of the pascal law)
please clarify...Thank you
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a hydraulic lift: two vertical cylinders joined at the bottom by a horizontal pipe, filled with liquid. Left piston labelled area A1 with a downward arrow and height x1; right piston labelled area A2 with an upward arrow and height x2.
    doubt.png
    1.9 KB · Views: 567
m*a1 is not the force on plate 1, no matter what "m" is.
m*a2 is not the force on plate 2, no matter what "m" is.

In particular, you can have a force without any acceleration.

Typically those problems assume that the acceleration is small and can be neglected. Otherwise Pascal's law needs modifications.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Dileep Ramisetty