Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the suitability of the book 'Number Theory with Computer Applications' by Ramanjuachary Kumandari and Christina Romero for beginners in a number theory course. Participants share their experiences with this book and suggest alternative texts, considering both theoretical and computational aspects of number theory.
Discussion Character
- Debate/contested
- Technical explanation
- Conceptual clarification
- Homework-related
Main Points Raised
- One participant inquires about the book 'Number Theory with Computer Applications' and seeks recommendations for personal library inclusion.
- Another participant suggests LeVeque's 'Fundamentals of Number Theory' as a better alternative, noting it is not computationally focused.
- Burton's book is recommended by some as a good introductory text, though it lacks computational content.
- Some participants express that LeVeque's book is dense and may require prior exposure to number theory concepts.
- A detailed course description is provided, outlining topics such as divisibility, congruences, quadratic reciprocity, and applications in cryptography.
- One participant mentions Richard Mollin's 'Fundamental Number Theory with Applications' as potentially relevant due to its focus on cryptography.
- Several participants recommend 'Introduction to Theory of Numbers' by Niven and Zuckerman, noting its age but affirming its value for learning number theory.
- Hardy's book is discussed, with mixed opinions on its organization and suitability for beginners.
- References to other texts, including 'Handbook of Applied Cryptography' and 'A Friendly Introduction to Number Theory' by Silverman, are made, highlighting their relevance to the course content.
- Some participants express personal attachments to specific texts based on their own learning experiences.
- Technical books related to cryptography and computational number theory are mentioned, with varying levels of accessibility noted.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants do not reach a consensus on the recommendation of 'Number Theory with Computer Applications.' Multiple competing views on suitable texts for beginners and the computational aspects of number theory remain evident throughout the discussion.
Contextual Notes
Participants express uncertainty regarding the computational focus of recommended texts and the appropriateness of various books for beginners. Some suggestions depend on specific course syllabi and individual learning preferences.