mfb
Mentor
- 37,402
- 14,231
So what. Would you say that OPERA has found superluminal neutrinos, because they claimed that (in the past)? Did CDF "find" this strange new particle, which was (probably) just a bad Monte Carlo description?Vanadium 50 said:Exactly. They will decide based on the evidence whether or not they are confident that they have something.
If the collaborations present some 5sigma-result, I'll be highly confident that they saw the Higgs. But it is not a binary decision - the confidence will just be higher than now.
A lot of cross-checks and other stuff, but usually nothing which boosts the significance in a significant way.Note that the collaborations also have additional evidence that is not public - every discovery (or decision that it's not a discovery) I have been involved with was informed by additional information that was not public at the time. For example, the outcome of a parallel analysis.