I Laser and hair - scattering or destructive interference?

Click For Summary
The discussion centers on the behavior of laser light interacting with human hair, specifically whether the observed patterns are due to destructive interference or scattering. Participants note that the interference pattern suggests wave properties of light rather than simple scattering, which typically does not produce such distinct patterns. It is clarified that the phenomenon observed is a combination of constructive and destructive interference, illustrating classical wave behavior rather than quantum mechanics. The conversation also touches on related concepts like diffraction and historical examples of light behavior. Ultimately, the experiment highlights the wave nature of light, reinforcing foundational principles in physics.
Spathi
Gold Member
Messages
102
Reaction score
10
TL;DR
However it is still unclear for me: is this a real destructive interference which illustrates the wave properties of photons, or simply a scattering (if the hair reflects the light at an angle)?
There is a video, where the author shows the interference of laser beam on a strand of human’s hair:



I bought a laser pointer and reproduced this experiment. Indeed, when a single hair is placed on the way of the laser beam, I see the “scattering” picture (a series of points with intervals of approximately 1 mm). However it is still unclear for me: is this a real destructive interference which illustrates the wave properties of photons, or simply a scattering (if the hair reflects the light at an angle)?
Later on the authors tries to explain that this experiment illustrates something “magical” with the light, but I didn’t yet understand her idea.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Spathi said:
However it is still unclear for me: is this a real destructive interference which illustrates the wave properties of photons, or simply a scattering (if the hair reflects the light at an angle)?
It's interference. Scattering from a near-homogenous object (like a hair) doesn't produce spaced patterns of light and dark spots.

Spathi said:
Later on the authors tries to explain that this experiment illustrates something “magical” with the light, but I didn’t yet understand her idea.
I didn't spend 15 minutes going through the whole video so I can't answer this. If you have a timestamp I'll be happy to watch it.
 
Spathi said:
However it is still unclear for me: is this a real destructive interference which illustrates the wave properties of photons, or simply a scattering (if the hair reflects the light at an angle)?
Neither, although it is destructive and constructive interference of light waves. It shows that light is a wave, a piece of classical physics observed early in the 19th century that has nothing to do with photons and quantum mechanics. To demonstrate any quantum behavior of light we need an experiment that builds up the interference pattern over time out of single-photon detections.
 
  • Like
Likes LittleSchwinger, vanhees71 and PeroK
You can think of diffraction around a narrow linear obstacle as sort of complementary to single-slit diffraction.

A related phenomenon is diffraction around a small 2-dimensional object such as a disk. This has a historically important example in Arago's spot, a.k.a. (ironically) Poisson's spot.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71 and PeroK
Both. What you are seeing is interference between the (planar) incident and (cylindrical) scattered wave.
 
We often see discussions about what QM and QFT mean, but hardly anything on just how fundamental they are to much of physics. To rectify that, see the following; https://www.cambridge.org/engage/api-gateway/coe/assets/orp/resource/item/66a6a6005101a2ffa86cdd48/original/a-derivation-of-maxwell-s-equations-from-first-principles.pdf 'Somewhat magically, if one then applies local gauge invariance to the Dirac Lagrangian, a field appears, and from this field it is possible to derive Maxwell’s...