Liquid Cooled Heat Exchanger Verification

Click For Summary
SUMMARY

The forum discussion focuses on the verification of a liquid-cooled heat exchanger design using four parallel nylon tubes with a thermal input of 265W. The calculations reveal that while conduction alone allows for a maximum water temperature of 296K, the combined effects of conduction and convection suggest a drastically lower effective temperature of 104.2K, indicating a potential error in the heat transfer calculations. The user seeks assistance in identifying discrepancies in their methodology, particularly in the application of the overall heat transfer equation and the assumptions made regarding heat transfer mechanisms.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of heat transfer principles, including conduction and convection
  • Familiarity with the overall heat transfer equation
  • Knowledge of Reynolds number and Nusselt number calculations
  • Experience with thermal properties of materials, specifically nylon
NEXT STEPS
  • Review the derivation and application of the overall heat transfer equation in heat exchanger design
  • Learn about the impact of flow regimes on heat transfer coefficients in liquid cooling systems
  • Investigate the effects of neglecting radiation and contact resistance in thermal analysis
  • Explore advanced heat exchanger design techniques, including optimization of tube arrangements
USEFUL FOR

Mechanical engineers, thermal system designers, and anyone involved in the design and analysis of heat exchangers will benefit from this discussion.

Raddy13
Messages
30
Reaction score
0
My friend and I are trying to design a simple liquid-cooled heat exchanger and I'm getting some odd results so I wanted to get another set of eyes on my math here. We're running four 1.5m sections of nylon tube in parallel through the heat source, which was a thermal input of 265W. The cooling loop will be supplied by a tank of cold water and pump. As the system runs, the water will gradually warm up, and once the the surface temperature of the nylon tube reaches 305K, we will consider that the point at which the water needs to be replaced/chilled, so I was trying to determine what the cold tank temperature would be at that point.

My assumptions:
*All thermal input is absorbed by the exchanger tube
*Heat is transferred to the water and tube by conduction and convection
*Neglect radiation and contact resistance
*The thermal input is equally divided among the four tubes

Known:
\dot{V}_{pump}=0.114 L/s
\dot{V}_{tube}=\frac{0.114}{4 tubes}=0.0285 L/s
OD_{tube}=0.953 cm
ID_{tube}=0.699 cm
L_{tube}=1.5m
k_{tube}=0.25 W/m \cdot K
T_H=305K
\dot{Q}_{per tube}=265W/4 tubes=66.25W

Using the overall heat transfer equation:
\dot{Q}=UA\Delta T

Where:
\frac{1}{UA}=\frac{1}{hA_{conv}}+\frac{d}{kA_{cond}}

For my convection coefficient, I got the following (check attached document for more complete work):
Re=2900
Pr=12.56
f=0.046
Nu=26.14
h=10.37 W/m^{2}\cdot K
A_{conv}=\pi (0.699cm)(1.5m)=0.033m^2

For the conduction term:
k_{tube}=0.25 W/m\cdot K
d=r_o - r_i =\frac{0.953cm-0.699cm}{2}=0.127cm
A_{cond}=\pi (0.953cm)(1.5m)=0.045m^2

Plugging it in:
\frac{1}{UA}=\frac{1}{(10.37)(0.033)} + \frac{0.127cm}{(0.25)(0.045)}=3.035
UA=0.33W/K

Substituting into the heat transfer equation:
66.25W=(0.33W/K)\Delta T
\Delta T = 200.8K
200.8K=T_H - T_C=305K-T_C
T_C=104.2K

Obviously a ridiculously low temperature. I thought that was odd, so I checked how much heat could be handled by conduction alone:
\dot{Q}=k\frac{2\pi L\Delta T}{ln(r_o/r_i)}
66.25W=(0.25 W/m\cdot K)\frac{2\pi (1.5m)\Delta T}{ln(0.477/0.350)}=\frac{2.36\Delta T}{0.309}
\Delta T=\frac{(66.25)(0.309)}{2.36}=8.67K

So according to conduction alone, the system will be effective until the water is 296K, but with conduction AND convection, it's only good until the water is 104.2K, which would be ice. Any idea where I'm screwing up?
 

Attachments

Engineering news on Phys.org
Raddy13 said:
... I thought that was odd, so I checked how much heat could be handled by conduction alone:
\dot{Q}=k\frac{2\pi L\Delta T}{ln(r_o/r_i)}
66.25W=(0.25 W/m\cdot K)\frac{2\pi (1.5m)\Delta T}{ln(0.477/0.350)}=\frac{2.36\Delta T}{0.309}
\Delta T=\frac{(66.25)(0.309)}{2.36}=8.67K

So according to conduction alone, the system will be effective until the water is 296K, but with conduction AND convection, it's only good until the water is 104.2K, which would be ice. Any idea where I'm screwing up?

The gives you the temperature ( 296K ) of the inner surface of the tube, not the water temp.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 34 ·
2
Replies
34
Views
6K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
4K
Replies
9
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K