I Longitudinal waves on a string

AI Thread Summary
A string does not necessarily need to be under tension to transmit longitudinal waves, but tension provides a restoring force that aids wave propagation. Longitudinal waves can occur in materials without pretension, though the characteristics may differ based on the material's structure. The discussion highlights that sound waves and longitudinal waves are closely related, but their speeds can vary depending on the medium. In stringed instruments, players can create longitudinal waves by sliding their fingers, resulting in higher pitch notes due to the faster propagation speed compared to transverse waves. Overall, understanding the dynamics of longitudinal waves in strings involves considering both the material properties and the effects of tension.
zongo123
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Good day to everyone,

I kindly ask for your help. My question is: "Does a string have to be under tension, to transmit longitudinal waves? Why is it so?" I have trouble finding relevant scientific articles regarding the question and for reasearching "longitudinal waves on a string". If anyone knows a good source for studying this, please point at that direction.

Thank you! Have a nice day :)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Hello @zongo123 ,
:welcome: !
Your question is definitely valid. But I think you could come up with some arguments alll by yourself. Take a piece of rope, fix one end and experiment.

For waves to propagate, whether longitutinal or transverse, there has to be some kind of restoring force. It's hard to imagine a restoring force in the absence of any tension whatsoever.

Do you agree ?

##\ ##
 
zongo123 said:
Does a string have to be under tension, to transmit longitudinal waves?
Technically a material can transmit sound even without pretension. But this might not be what is meant by "longitudinal waves in a string". For example, in a string made of fibers the sound speed within the fiber material can be different than the longitudinal wave speed in the whole compound, where fibers change shape and move relative to each other.
 
  • Like
Likes sophiecentaur
What do you think is the difference between a sound wave and a longitudinal wave? And how can the sound speed within the material differ from that of a longitudinal wave? I would say they are the same thing.
 
Arjan82 said:
And how can the sound speed within the material differ from that of a longitudinal wave?
The question is about a "string" which is not a material. It is an object that can contain parts of various geometries and materials.

Consider the difference between the longitudinal wave propagating along the axis of a spring vs. the sound propagating in wire the spring is made of.
 
  • Like
Likes nasu
I have been told that when playing a stringed instrument such as a guitar, players can cause longitudinal waves to propagate along a string when they slide their fingers along the string. You hear this as a note with a higher pitch because longitudinal waves propagate faster than transverse waves in a guitar spring.
 
  • Like
Likes sophiecentaur
The speed of longitudinal waves would certainly be a lot higher than transverse waves on a string so resonances would be a lot higher. The fact that the squeaks can be so loud would suggest that there could be resonances involved. (Those squeaks are only (afair) set up on the wound strings.)

Edit [ I suggest that the 'surface wave mode' could also exist (Thick and thin cross sections) - slower than straight compression wave but faster than transverse]
 
Last edited:
The Yamaha G12 midi guitar relies on longitudinal waves to measure distance from bridge to the fret the string is pressed against. Any transverse waves are ignored.
 
  • Like
Likes sophiecentaur
Back
Top