The discussion focuses on the energy loss of electrons and protons due to radiation, specifically in the context of acceleration within particle accelerators. It establishes that both particles emit electromagnetic radiation when accelerated, with the phenomenon known as "synchrotron radiation" being particularly relevant. The conversation emphasizes that the energy loss is contingent upon the acceleration and the specific conditions of the system, rather than spontaneous emission. Ultimately, the comparison of energy loss between electrons and protons is complex and depends on the scenario of acceleration.
PREREQUISITESPhysicists, particle accelerator operators, and students studying particle physics who seek to understand the dynamics of energy loss in charged particles during acceleration.
What radiation emissions are you talking about here?Adams2020 said:
Electromagnetic radiationPeroK said:
What scenario are you thinking of? An electron isn't constantly spontaneously emitting EM radiation. It creates an electric field - perhaps you are thinking of that?Adams2020 said:
I did not mean spontaneously. Does it not emit radiation when the electron is accelerated?PeroK said:
That's the first you've mentioned acceleration. What sort of acceleration? Do you have a particular experiment in mind? If not, your question is like asking whether a car or a motorbike loses more energy when it brakes?Adams2020 said:
I do not know its sort. Suppose it is inside a particle accelerator.PeroK said:
thanksvanhees71 said:
