Mass submerged in oil and scales problem

1 reply · 10K views · last reply
bdh2991
Messages
102
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



A 1.02 kg beaker containing 1.98 kg of oil (density = 916.0 kg/m3) rests on a scale. A 1.98 kg block of iron is suspended from a spring scale and completely submerged in the oil. Determine the equilibrium readings of both scales.

Diagram of a block submerged in a beaker of oil hanging from a spring scale, with the beaker resting on a dial scale below.



What does the top scale read?

What does the bottom scale read?

Homework Equations



Fbuoyant = ρ*g*Vdisplaced

Fg = mg

T = tension

The Attempt at a Solution



For the top scale I did the sum of the forces, therefore i get:

ƩF = T + Fbuoyant - mblock*g = 0

substituting buoyant force I get: T + ρoil*g*Vdisplaced - mg = 0

At first I thought I couldn't get the volume but then i figured since the density*volume = mass, that it would just be equal to mblock*g, however that would mean the T = 0 and the top scale reads zero. I do not believe this is the right answer however.

For the second part I also did sum of the forces for the beaker:

ƩF = Fbuoyant + mbeaker*g + moil*g = bottom scale reading.

solving for that i got 48.804 N, but that is also assuming Fbuoyant = mblock*g

Any help?
 
At first I thought I couldn't get the volume but then i figured since the density*volume = mass, that it would just be equal to mblock*g, however that would mean the T = 0 and the top scale reads zero. I do not believe this is the right answer however.
Nicely analysed.

However - the iron (Fe) is not floating.
##F_{bouy}=\rho_{oil}V_{Fe}g## and ##\rho_{oil}V_{Fe}\neq m_{Fe}##