Master's Thesis OR Comprehensive Exam?

In summary, the conversation discusses the benefits and drawbacks of pursuing a thesis or comprehensive exam for a master's in electrical engineering. The thesis route allows for a work product that can be shown to prospective employers and demonstrates the ability to independently complete a project. It may also be helpful in impressing employers and getting a fast track to becoming a top-level engineer. However, it may take longer to complete and may not be necessary for certain job opportunities. On the other hand, a comprehensive exam can be completed in a few hours but may not provide the same level of experience and learning as a thesis. Ultimately, it is up to the individual to decide which route will best suit their goals and aspirations.
  • #1
CanIExplore
99
0
Hello Forum,

I'm a first year graduate student in a Master's in electrical engineering program. I am currently taking several graduate courses in different fields so that I may make the very important decision of what to focus on in my later coursework. I would like to ask those of you with similar experience, what the benefits and drawbacks of going the thesis route versus the comprehensive exam are for a master's in EE? I am asking this question in a very general sense, as I'm sure this can vary on different circumstances. I am coming from the perspective of wanting to go straight into industry after completing my master's degree and not continuing on for a Ph.D. I am unsure of whether I will head into the semiconductor field or wireless circuit design. But in general, is there a large advantage to going the thesis route from the perspective of an employer? Or is a master's degree simply a master's degree regardless of how you got it.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The thesis is a work product which you can show to a prospective employer in your portfolio.

It would be especially useful if it matches up with the area in which you are seeking work.
 
  • #3
A MS is just an MS once you're a few years out of school. The real difference is getting that first job. The thesis is work product as UltrafastPED said. A completed thesis indicates you completed a challenging project, which is an important job skill. If you do an exam, you did well in your courses but you haven't demonstrated that you can independently complete a project. That's important.

If you have an inside track to a company or a set of companies (from connections or internships or whatever) a comprehensive exam is fine. I have several friends who went that route. If you want to impress employers and get an a fast track to be a top-level engineer, a highly relevant thesis would be a great step. That way you have something solid to talk about at an interview and you're going to be less of a risk from the hiring manager's standpoint.
 
  • #4
To some degree a MS is just an MS. But a thesis does becomes something you can present to demonstrate your knowledge in an area in addition to your actual MS. That may or may not matter, but it can't hurt.
 
  • #5
On the other hand, a comprehensive exam will be finished in a few hours. A master's thesis will be done when it's done...
 
  • #6
Another thing: While an MS might just be an MS after your first job, YOU might get more out of a thesis than the exam. While it's great if you can translate that into an interview and increase your chances of getting a job, even if it doesn't, the learning experience of doing a thesis can make you a better person and employee. It can expand your experience as to what types of projects you have undertaken, which could be valuable insight to have at some point.
 
  • #7
TMFKAN64 said:
On the other hand, a comprehensive exam will be finished in a few hours. A master's thesis will be done when it's done...

That is true. I took the easy way out and didn't do a thesis but I also already had about 8 years work experience when I created my Masters. I would have preferred to do a thesis but didn't really have the time with work and other commitments.
 

1. What is the difference between a Master's Thesis and a Comprehensive Exam?

Both a Master's Thesis and a Comprehensive Exam are required for students to complete their graduate degree. A thesis is a research-based project that demonstrates a student's ability to conduct independent research and contribute new knowledge to their field. On the other hand, a comprehensive exam is a comprehensive assessment of a student's knowledge and understanding of their graduate program's core concepts and theories.

2. How long does it take to complete a Master's Thesis or Comprehensive Exam?

The length of time to complete a Master's Thesis or Comprehensive Exam varies depending on the program and the student's progress. However, on average, a Master's Thesis can take 1-2 years to complete, while a Comprehensive Exam can take several months to prepare for and complete.

3. How do I choose a topic for my Master's Thesis?

The process of choosing a topic for a Master's Thesis can vary, but it typically involves consulting with your advisor or professor, researching current literature in your field, and identifying a gap in knowledge or a research question that interests you. It is important to choose a topic that aligns with your interests and expertise, and that is feasible to complete within the given time frame.

4. What is the format of a Master's Thesis or Comprehensive Exam?

The format of a Master's Thesis or Comprehensive Exam can vary depending on the program and department. However, a Master's Thesis usually follows a traditional research paper format, while a Comprehensive Exam may include written essays, oral presentations, or a combination of both.

5. Can I change my topic or research question for my Master's Thesis?

Yes, it is possible to change your topic or research question for your Master's Thesis, but it is important to consult with your advisor or professor before making any changes. Changing your topic may require additional time and resources, so it is important to carefully consider the implications before making a change.

Similar threads

  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
5
Views
822
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
2
Replies
50
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
811
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
23
Views
3K
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
5
Views
190
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
2K
Back
Top