Mathematical Methods in the Physical Sciences (alternative?)

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on finding alternative mathematical methods books that either simplify problem-solving or provide clearer explanations of concepts. The original book mentioned, "Mathematical Methods for Physicists," is criticized for being confusing and not fully meeting the needs of students. Recommendations include looking for books that present core concepts in an accessible manner, akin to a "mathematical methods for dummies" approach, as well as those that offer clear problem-solving steps. Notable suggestions include "Mathematical Methods for Physicists" by Arfken and Weber, which is recognized for its practical application in solving physics problems. Other classic texts like Morse & Feshbach, Courant & Hilbert, and Mathews & Walker are acknowledged but noted for their complexity. Modern alternatives are also suggested, with a focus on books that balance rigor and readability for undergraduate students.
RaulTheUCSCSlug
Gold Member
Messages
179
Reaction score
28
Is there any alternative books that teach you how to just do the problems rather than emphasizing why, and is there any books that emphasize why in an easier format? Something like a "mathematical methods for dummies" book?

This is the book I'm referring to ( https://www.amazon.com/dp/0471198269/?tag=pfamazon01-20 ) if you are not familiar with it and I personally think that the book is not the best. I dislike it. It seems to be in between of what could be two great books. Some of the problems are really great, some explanations are great, but other times it is a bit confusing and I can't decipher what they are saying.

I guess I'm looking for two book suggestions:
1.) Simple to read through and get core concepts ("explain to me as if I was 5" type of book)
2.) A good book with problems and solutions that go through the steps very clearly with a solution

Thank you for your recommendations.

I heard a book by Arfkin is good, does anyone know the name of the book?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
RaulTheUCSCSlug said:
This is the book I'm referring to ( https://www.amazon.com/dp/0471198269/?tag=pfamazon01-20 ) if you are not familiar with it and I personally think that the book is not the best.
I enjoyed that book during my undergrad. But I must admit that this book presents its content mostly in a readily-applicable-to-solve-physics-problem manner - it's a practical textbook in my opinion. The author does the derivations adjusted to how physics students will use the math to solve physical problem. Nevertheless, to me the explanations are clear and accessible as this book is largely designed for undergrads.
RaulTheUCSCSlug said:
I heard a book by Arfkin is good, does anyone know the name of the book?
Probably you mean "Mathematical Methods for Physicists" by Arfken and Weber. I heard this book is also commonly used among physics students, but I don't know to which level of college it is aligned.
 
blue_leaf77 said:
I enjoyed that book during my undergrad. But I must admit that this book presents its content mostly in a readily-applicable-to-solve-physics-problem manner - it's a practical textbook in my opinion. .

Do you have a recommendation of any other mathematical methods books that would be a bit easier to comprehend? I feel myself getting lost in the jumps boas does from explaining the basic concepts to jumping straight to certain complex ideas with little explanation.
 
RaulTheUCSCSlug said:
Do you have a recommendation of any other mathematical methods books that would be a bit easier to comprehend?
This undergraduate book is more rigorous than Boas', since you appear to be looking for a more formal treatment for the derivations.
 
  • Like
Likes RaulTheUCSCSlug
TL;DR Summary: Book after Sakurai Modern Quantum Physics I am doing a comprehensive reading of sakurai and I have solved every problem from chapters I finished on my own, I will finish the book within 2 weeks and I want to delve into qft and other particle physics related topics, not from summaries but comprehensive books, I will start a graduate program related to cern in 3 months, I alreadily knew some qft but now I want to do it, hence do a good book with good problems in it first...
This is part 2 of my thread Collection of Free Online Math Books and Lecture Notes Here, we will consider physics and mathematical methods for physics resources. Now, this is a work in progress. Please feel free comment regarding items you want to be included, or if a link is broken etc. Note: I will not post links to other collections, each link will point you to a single item. :book:📚📒 [FONT=trebuchet ms]Introductory college/university physics College Physics, Openstax...
Back
Top