A matrix A is invertible if and only if its reduced row echelon form (RREF) is the identity matrix. The discussion emphasizes understanding the implications of row operations on matrix algebra, particularly how they relate to the invertibility of A. If the RREF does not yield the identity matrix, it indicates a row of zeros, leading to a determinant of zero and confirming that A is not invertible. The participants suggest that while the proof may seem straightforward, exploring the relationship between row operations and matrix properties can enhance understanding. Overall, the connection between RREF and matrix invertibility is crucial in linear algebra.