Moment of Inertia with varying distance from Centre of Mass

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the moment of inertia (MoI) for a T-shaped pendulum using the distances from the center of mass (COM) of its vertical and horizontal components. The distances d1 and d2 are defined based on the pivot point and the COM of each section, with a specific value of 0.08 m derived from the diagram. Participants confirm the calculations for the MoI, but there is confusion regarding the definition of mass (m) in the context of the pendulum's total mass versus the mass of individual strips. Ultimately, it is emphasized that consistency in defining mass is crucial for relating the MoI to the pendulum's period.
Ang09
Messages
5
Reaction score
3
Homework Statement
A T-shaped card is made of two pieces of thin cardboard sticked together with tape. Each of this cardboard is 0.28 m by 0.04 m. There are several holes along the vertical portion of the T-shape. The T-shaped card is pivoted one of the holes along the vertical portion of the T-shape.

In term of h (where h is the distance between the pivot and the centre of mass of the T-shaped card), what is the moment of inertia of the T-shaped card ?
Relevant Equations
Moment of inertia of a thin card I = 1/12 m(l^2 + b^2) where l and b are length and breadth of card
I = Icom + md^2
T shaped Pendulum.JPG


h = d1 + 0.08
d1 = h - 0.08

d2 = h + 0.08

I of the vertical portion
= 1/12 m (l^2 + b^2) + md1^2
= 1/12 m (0.28^2 + 0.04^2) + m(h - 0.08)^2

I of the horizontal portion
= 1/12 m (l^2 + b^2) + md2^2
= 1/12 m (0.28^2 + 0.04^2) + m(h + 0.08)^2

The moment of inertia for the whole T-shape about the pivot (of distance h away from centre of mass) =
= 1/12 m (0.28^2 + 0.04^2) + m(h - 0.08)^2 + 1/12 m (0.28^2 + 0.04^2) + m(h + 0.08)^2
= 1/6 m (0.28^2 + 0.04^2) + 2m(h^2 + 0.08^2)
= 2mh^2 + 0.02613 m

Wondering if my calculation is correct ?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Delta2
Physics news on Phys.org
How are you defining d1 and d2? Where does the 0.08 come from?
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
d1 is the distance between pivot and centre of mass of the vertical portion
d2 is the distance between pivot and centre of mass of the horizontal portion
(Refer to picture)

The 0.08 m is derived based on the diagram to relate the centre of mass of the vertical and horizontal portion to the pivot.

T-shaped pendulum.JPG
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2
The computation of the centre of mass is based on something that i search online.
[Link deleted by the Mentors]

T-shaped pendulum1.jpg

My computation was:-
COM of the horizontal part y1: 0.02 m from the base of the horizontal part
COM of the vertical part y2: (0.14 + 0.04=) 0.18 m from the base of the horizontal part

COM of the T-shaped pendulum
= (Area1 * y1 + Area2 * y2) / (Area1 + Area2)
= (0.28*0.04 *0.02 + 0.28*0.04 *0.018) / (0.28*0.04 + 0.28*0.04)
= 0.10 m
Hence it is 0.08 m away from both of the COM of the horizontal and vertical part.

I guess it may be wrong. May I ask what is the center of mass of the two strips?

By the way, is the computation steps for the moment of inertia of T-shaped pendulum correct? i.e. if i can find the correct center of mass, would the steps above allow me to find the moment of inertia of the T-shaped pendulum in terms of h?

Thank you for your advice in advance.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • Like
Likes Delta2
Ang09 said:
The computation of the centre of mass is based on something that i search online.
[Link deleted by the Mentors]

View attachment 284264
My computation was:-
COM of the horizontal part y1: 0.02 m from the base of the horizontal part
COM of the vertical part y2: (0.14 + 0.04=) 0.18 m from the base of the horizontal part

COM of the T-shaped pendulum
= (Area1 * y1 + Area2 * y2) / (Area1 + Area2)
= (0.28*0.04 *0.02 + 0.28*0.04 *0.018) / (0.28*0.04 + 0.28*0.04)
= 0.10 m
Hence it is 0.08 m away from both of the COM of the horizontal and vertical part.

I guess it may be wrong. May I ask what is the center of mass of the two strips?

By the way, is the computation steps for the moment of inertia of T-shaped pendulum correct? i.e. if i can find the correct center of mass, would the steps above allow me to find the moment of inertia of the T-shaped pendulum in terms of h?

Thank you for your advice in advance.
I am very sorry - I was writing rubbish.
Let me try again.. give me a few minutes.

Yes, your calculation looks ok, but the question as posted does not define m.
Should it be the mass of the whole shape or the mass of each strip?
 
Last edited:
Sorry.. i am not clear in my working..
  • the m in the 0.02 m and 0.18 m are the unit (metre).
  • the m in the moment of inertia is the mass of each strip.
 
Ang09 said:
[*]the m in the moment of inertia is the mass of each strip.
Yes, but in post #1 we are asked to find an MoI without being given a mass, neither as "m" nor as a numerical quantity. Does the original question say the mass of each strip is m, that the mass of the whole shape is m, or are you left to make something up?
 
The original ques did not state the mass of the t-shape pendulum nor the mass of each cardboard. Only inform that the two cardboard are identical/similar. So I assume that each cardboard's mass is m.
Need that when I relate the MoI of the pendulum to its period.
 
Ang09 said:
The original ques did not state the mass of the t-shape pendulum nor the mass of each cardboard. Only inform that the two cardboard are identical/similar. So I assume that each cardboard's mass is m.
Need that when I relate the MoI of the pendulum to its period.
Ok.
For finding the period, it should not matter whether you take m as the mass of each or as the combined mass, provided you are consistent.
 
Back
Top