How Do You Calculate Particle Motion in the x-y Plane?

Click For Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating particle motion in the x-y plane using polar coordinates. The equations provided describe the particle's position and involve converting polar coordinates to Cartesian coordinates for various calculations. Participants express confusion about applying the correct formulas for position, velocity, and acceleration, particularly emphasizing the importance of using the chain rule in differentiation. After some back-and-forth, one participant successfully resolves their misunderstanding regarding the relationship between the components of motion and the differentiation process. The conversation highlights the necessity of understanding instantaneous velocity and the correct application of calculus in solving the problem.
fruitl00p
Messages
93
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


The motion of a particle moving in a circle in the x-y plane is described by the equations: r(t)=9.71, theta(t)=8.74t. Where theta is the polar angle measured counter clockwise from the + x-axis in radians, and r is the distance from the origin in m.
A. Calculate the y-coordinate of the particle at the time 1.60s.
B. Calculate the y-component of the velocity at the time 3.40s.
C. Calculate the magnitude of the acceleration of the particle at the time 1s.
D. By how much does the speed of the particle change from t=10s to t=67s?
E. Calculate the x-component of the acceleration at the time 2.20s.

Homework Equations



r(t)=9.71
theta(t)=8.74t

The Attempt at a Solution


I usually try to make several attempts before I ask for help, but I don't even know where to begin! How do I go about this 5 part problem? Please help me :confused:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Do you know expressions relating polar coordinates to cartesian coordinates? If not, try drawing a diagram!
 
I just know that x= r cos theta and y= r sin theta
So...to find part A I do y= r(t)sin (theta(t))?
Unfortunately, I don't see how I can use that for parts B through E.
 
fruitl00p said:
I just know that x= r cos theta and y= r sin theta
So...to find part A I do y= r(t)sin (theta(t))?
Unfortunately, I don't see how I can use that for parts B through E.

Well, how are position and velocity related?
 
I know that velocity= distance/time...
I just tried part A and got that incorrect. I did y=r(t)*sin(theta(t)). Why is that incorrect?
 
fruitl00p said:
I know that velocity= distance/time...
I just tried part A and got that incorrect. I did y=r(t)*sin(theta(t)). Why is that incorrect?

Until you present your work, I'll be unable to conclude why it's incorrect.
 
when I tried part A I put in y= 9.71*sin (8.74*1.60)
 
fruitl00p said:
when I tried part A I put in y= 9.71*sin (8.74*1.60)

fruitl00p said:
Where theta is the polar angle measured counter clockwise from the + x-axis in radians

Is your calculator set to radians?
 
It wasn't. I just switched it to radians.
 
  • #10
Now I got the correct answer for part A. Thank you for pointing that out.

I know you wrote about the relationship between velocity and position but I cannot figure out the relationship in this coordinate system... I understand for poisition in the y component, it will be r*sin(theta(t)), but I'm lost after that.

I understand for part C that I need to find the x and y components of acceleration in order to find the magnitude of acceleration...but how do I figure out the equation for acceleration for this coordinate system?
 
  • #11
fruitl00p said:
but how do I figure out the equation for acceleration for this coordinate system?

Again, look at post #4, look at your answer at post #5, and try to give a precise relation.
 
  • #12
Radou, I'm sorry if I am slow at figuring out how to do this problem!

I looked at post 4 and 5 again... since velocity=distance/time, then I can find velocity of the y component using Vy = r*sin(theta(t)/ t

and since acceleration is equal to the change in velocity divided by the change in time, then Ax= (r*cos(theta(t))/t)/t
Ay= (r*sin(theta (t))/t)/t
and proceed from there.
 
  • #13
fruitl00p said:
Radou, I'm sorry if I am slow at figuring out how to do this problem!

I looked at post 4 and 5 again... since velocity=distance/time, then I can find velocity of the y component using Vy = r*sin(theta(t)/ t

and since acceleration is equal to the change in velocity divided by the change in time, then Ax= (r*cos(theta(t))/t)/t
Ay= (r*sin(theta (t))/t)/t
and proceed from there.

No need to apologize.

I suggest you look up the term 'instantaneous velocity'.
 
  • #14
Before I viewed your response I attempted v= r*sintheta(t)/t and I got an incorrect answer.

I found out that the angle theta increases linearly with time so the speed v is constant and is given by r*d(theta)/dt and that r is constant in problem.
Which I think deals with what you said...instantaneous velocity.

So since this is dealing with derivative, then theta(t) becomes just theta and t goes away? Then Vy=r*theta. Or is it Vy=r*theta(t)/t?
 
  • #15
I attempted Vy=(9.71m)*(8.74*3.40s)= 84.86 m/s. But that is incorrect.
So after looking at your last post radou, I've been looking at the concept of instantaneous velocity. I understand its the first derivative of a position equation. Which is why at one point I thought v=r*theta which turns out to be 84.86 m/s as well.

Then I realized that it is still a y component, so Vy=r*sintheta* d(theta)/dt
I then did Vy=9.71*sin(8.74*3.40s)*(8.74*3.40)/3.40= -84.15m/s and that was incorrect. Can someone please tell me why that is incorrect?
 
  • #16
Hint: chain rule for differetiation.
 
  • #17
When using calculus velocity is much better defined as V=\frac{ds}{dt} rather than distance/time.
 
  • #18
radou, if I differentiate the equation theta(t), then it would be just theta, right? So then Vy=r*sin(theta(t)*theta. But when I put (9.71)*sin(8.74*3.40)*8.74=Vy, Vy still ends up equalling -84.15 m/s.

Is my differentiation wrong?

Gib Z, I will try what you suggested, but what happens to r? Since s=r*theta,

would d(theta)/dt= 1/r *ds/dt?
 
  • #19
Ok, so I read more on differentiation and instantaneous velocity, etc.
And I was right that d(theta)/dt ends up being theta.
I went on to solve part c and part e.
Yet I cannot solve part b. Once again, I put in r*sintheta(t)* theta=-9.71*sin(8.74*3.40)*8.74= 84.15 m/s and that of course was incorrect.

I now know I am on the right track since I solved part e doing Ax= -theta^2*r*costheta(t).

What am I doing wrong?:bugeye:
 
  • #20
fruitl00p said:
Once again, I put in r*sintheta(t)* theta=-9.71*sin(8.74*3.40)*8.74= 84.15 m/s and that of course was incorrect.

What am I doing wrong?:bugeye:

It seems your differentiation is wrong.
 
  • #21
You were told before- think chain rule.

If both \theta and r are functions of t,
With y(t)= r(t) cos(\theta(t))
\frac{dy}{dt}= \frac{dr}{dt}cos(\theta(t))- r(t)sin(\theta(t))\frac{d\theta}{dt}[/itex]<br /> <br /> You were told &quot;(t)=9.71, theta(t)=8.74t &quot; so what are dr/dt and d\theta /dt?
 
  • #22
Ok, after thinking about the problem some more, I realized what my problem was- I just assumed that because they are asking for the y component that the equation should mirror part a. I made a picture, etc. and found that I was wrong. Instead I know now that Vy= r*costheta(t)*theta. And I got the right answer now.

Thank you everyone though, because I wouldn't have gotten to that point without everyone's suggestions.

I'm not sure how to approach part d but I'm going to work on that first before asking for help
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 40 ·
2
Replies
40
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 35 ·
2
Replies
35
Views
5K