MTW Gravitation Electronic Notebook

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the need for electronic solutions to exercise mathematical formulations, particularly in the context of gravitational physics as outlined in the book "Gravitation" by Misner, Thorne, and Wheeler (MTW G). Users express a desire for tools that facilitate symbolic math, as many real-world simulations yield only numerical solutions. Mathcad has been previously utilized for algebraic equations, but there is interest in exploring cosmological simulation software like EAGLE, although details on its programming language and support libraries are unclear. The conversation highlights the importance of numerical ordinary differential equation (ODE) algorithms in simulating complex systems, such as the three-body problem, which can exhibit significant errors depending on the chosen algorithm. These errors can affect the stability of the simulation, emphasizing the need for careful selection of numerical methods to maintain accuracy over time.
rayj
Messages
14
Reaction score
6
TL;DR Summary
Options for electronic notebooks to exercise equations in general relativity using notation of MTW G.
I would like to exercise the formulations in the book. I have read Gravitation and many others but I need to do more exercises. I get very bogged down in writing out the symbols. Are there electronic solutions for writing and exercising these equations? I have used Mathcad to perform algebraic equations. I would love to be able to do this as a companion to MTW G.

Any suggestions?
 
Computer science news on Phys.org
Perhaps look to cosmoslogical simulation software.

I found this one called EAGLE but not sure where you can get the code or even what programming language and support libs are used.

http://icc.dur.ac.uk/Eagle/

Langauge wise you might find some code for Julia which is being used in a lot of computational projects.
 
jedishrfu

That was a great site with wonderful information.

Yes, there is the possibility of obtaining code for calculations.

My primary concern is to be able to perform the symbolic math.
 
Most real-world simulations of complex systems do not yield analytical solutions (ie a symbolic solution won't be available) only numerical ones. The simplest case of the three-body problem is one:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-body_problem

As you an see, there are solutions that while quite beautiful, are not analytical but can be computed numerically. Introductory courses often use this system to help the student understand the best algorithms to choose based on whether the system is periodic or not.

All numerical ODE algorithms introduce some form of error that manifests itself as energy added or removed from the system. The trick for a periodic system is to choose an algorithm that adds some error and then takes away some error periodically allowing the solution to stay stable longer.

In the course I took, the prof had us swap in different ODE algorithms. In some cases, the planets spiraled into each other, in other cases they flew apart.
 
Well, the date has now passed, and Windows 10 is no longer supported. Hopefully, the readers of this forum have done one of the many ways this issue can be handled. If not, do a YouTube search and a smorgasbord of solutions will be returned. What I want to mention is that I chose to use a debloated Windows from a debloater. There are many available options, e.g., Chris Titus Utilities (I used a product called Velotic, which also features AI to prevent your computer from overheating etc...
After playing around a bit with making star maps, I found another video which introduced me to another trick that can be done using geometry nodes. This one involves fluids. For background, Blender has a fluid physics simulator, which, as the name suggests simulates the behavior of fluids. What this person did was to use geometry nodes to convert the fluid into a point cloud. Then he added a turbulence force field to "stir it around". He was then able to extract the velocity information...
I have been idly browsing what Apple have to offer with their new iPhone17. There is mention of 'Vapour cooling' to deal with the heat generated. Would that be the same sort of idea that was used in 'Heat Pipes' where water evaporated at the processor end and liquid water was returned from the cool end and back along a wick. At the extreme high power end, Vapour Phase Cooling has been used in multi-kW RF transmitters where (pure) water was pumped to the Anode / or alternative Collector and...

Similar threads

Back
Top