Multi-Plate variable Capacitor Questions.

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the calculations and concepts related to a multi-plate variable capacitor, specifically focusing on estimating the required radius of the plates and analyzing the circuit behavior when charged. The scope includes theoretical calculations, unit conversions, and the application of relevant equations.

Discussion Character

  • Homework-related
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification

Main Points Raised

  • Participants discuss the formula for capacitance and its dependence on plate area, distance, and permittivity values (εr and ε0).
  • Some participants propose calculations for the required plate area and radius based on the capacitance value of 400 pF.
  • There is a challenge regarding the correct interpretation of the area calculation, particularly whether the plates are full circles or semicircles.
  • Participants express uncertainty about unit conversions, with some noting discrepancies in the area calculations and suggesting corrections.
  • Multiple participants verify the initial current and time constant calculations, with some confirming their plausibility.
  • There are discussions about the need to multiply the area by 2 if the plates are semicircles, leading to further calculations for the radius.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the formulas used for capacitance and current calculations, but there is disagreement and uncertainty regarding the area calculations and the interpretation of the plate shapes. The discussion remains unresolved on some aspects of the calculations and unit conversions.

Contextual Notes

Limitations include potential errors in unit conversions and assumptions about the geometry of the plates (full circles vs. semicircles), which affect the area calculations. Some participants express confusion about the application of the equations and the resulting values.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for students or individuals interested in capacitor design, electrical engineering concepts, and those seeking clarification on related mathematical calculations and unit conversions.

oxon88
Messages
176
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement



A multi-plate variable capacitor has 4 pairs of plates. The plates, when closed, are separated in air by 0.01mm. A capacitance range of 10 - 400 pF is required

a) estimate the required radius, R of each plate.

b) The capacitor is set to the maximum of 400 pF and is charged to 10v through a 50KΩ resistor. determine: i) the initial value of current flowing. ii) the time constant for the circuit.
IMAG0096.jpg

Homework Equations



capacitance = εr ε0A(n-1) / d

Initial current = V/R

Time constant = R x C

The Attempt at a Solution



a) 400x10-12 = εr ε0A(8-1) / (1x10-5)

can anyone explain what these 2 values are? (εr & ε0) i think one is dialectric strength. which for air is 3MV m-1 ?

b)
i) 10V/50Kohm = 0.2mA

ii) (50x103) x (400x10-12) = 20 μs
 
Physics news on Phys.org
oxon88 said:

The Attempt at a Solution



can anyone explain what these 2 values are? (εr & ε0) i think one is dialectric strength. which for air is 3MV m-1 ?

##\epsilon_o = 8.8542\times10^{-12}\;F m^{-1}## is the permittivity of vacuum (free space)

##\epsilon_r = 1.00058986## is the relative permittivity for air
 
Ok thanks, so...3. The Attempt at a Solution

a) 400x10-12 = 1 x (8.8542x10-12)A(8-1) / (1x10-5)re-arranging for A.

A = C.d / ϵorA = (400x10-12)*(1x10-5) / (8.8542x10-12)

A = 0.451763x10-3 = 0.451763 mm2A= ∏r2

r = √(a/∏)

r = √(0.451763x10-3/∏) = 11.99mm

can anyone check if this is ok?b)
i) 10V/50Kohm = 0.2mA

ii) (50x103) x (400x10-12) = 20 μsdo these answers look plausible?
 
Last edited:
oxon88 said:
Ok thanks, so...


3. The Attempt at a Solution

a) 400x10-12 = 1 x (8.8542x10-12)A(8-1) / (1x10-5)


re-arranging for A.

A = C.d / ϵor
Oops. What happened to the "(8 - 1)" ?
A = (400x10-12)*(1x10-5) / (8.8542x10-12)

A = 0.451763x10-3 = 0.451763 mm2


A= ∏r2
Are the plate areas full circles?
r = √(a/∏)

r = √(0.451763x10-3/∏) = 11.99mm

can anyone check if this is ok?


b)
i) 10V/50Kohm = 0.2mA

ii) (50x103) x (400x10-12) = 20 μs
These last two look fine.
 
oops forgot about that. got carried away! :Da) 400x10-12 = 1 x (8.8542x10-12)A(8-1) / (1x10-5)re-arranging for A.

A = C.d / ϵor(n-1)A = (400x10-12)*(1x10-5) / (8.8542x10-12)(7)

A =0.0645376x10-3 = 0.06454mm

A= ∏r2

r = √(a/∏)

r = √(0.0645376x10-3/∏) = 4.532mmthey are half circles

so if i multiply the Area by 2.

0.064545x10-3*2 =0.1290752x10-3

then work out the radius:

r = √(0.1290752x10-3/∏) = 6.4098mm
 
Last edited:
oxon88 said:
oops forgot about that. got carried away! :D


a) 400x10-12 = 1 x (8.8542x10-12)A(8-1) / (1x10-5)


re-arranging for A.

A = C.d / ϵor(n-1)

A = (400x10-12)*(1x10-5) / (8.8542x10-12)(7)

A =0.0645376x10-3 = 0.06454mm
I think you have a unit conversion problem; The area should be three orders of magnitude larger if it's in mm2 (and it's mm2, not mm as you've written). Note that an area of 0.06 mm2 would be practically microscopic! That should be a tipoff that something's amiss :wink:
A= ∏r2
Again, are the plates full circles?
 
ok. I'm not really sure where I'm going wrong here.



a)

C = (ϵor(n-1)) / d

C = 400x10-12 Farads
ϵo = 8.8542×10−12Fm−1
ϵr = 1.00058986
d = 1x10-5 m


400x10-12 = 1 x (8.8542x10-12)A(8-1) / (1x10-5)


re-arranging for A.

A = C.d / ϵor(n-1) is equation ok?



A = (400x10-12)*(1x10-5) / 7(8.8542x10-12)

A =0.066896x10-3 mm2
 
oxon88 said:
ok. I'm not really sure where I'm going wrong here.
a)

C = (ϵor(n-1)) / d

C = 400x10-12 Farads
ϵo = 8.8542×10−12Fm−1
ϵr = 1.00058986
d = 1x10-5 m400x10-12 = 1 x (8.8542x10-12)A(8-1) / (1x10-5)re-arranging for A.

A = C.d / ϵor(n-1) is equation ok?

Yes, that's fine.
A = (400x10-12)*(1x10-5) / 7(8.8542x10-12)

A = 6.45 x 10-5 m2

6.45 x 10-5 m2 x (106 mm2/m2) = 64.5 mm2
 
ok thanks for that. I've never been great with unit conversions. :blushing:



so now do I multiply the calulated area by 2 because the plates are semicircles?

A = 64.5376mm2*2 = 129mm2


then work out the radius...

r = √(129/∏) = 6.41mm
 
  • #10
oxon88 said:
ok thanks for that. I've never been great with unit conversions. :blushing:
so now do I multiply the calulated area by 2 because the plates are semicircles?

A = 64.5376mm2*2 = 129mm2then work out the radius...

r = √(129/∏) = 6.41mm

That works fine. You could also have said that each plate is a semicircle so it has area

##A = \frac{1}{2}\pi r^2##

It works out to the same thing.
Looks like you're done :smile:
 
  • #11
many thanks for your help and patients.
 

Similar threads

Replies
25
Views
21K
Replies
17
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
7K
Replies
1
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
6K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
8K