Musing on which element discussed most in physics class

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the importance of various elements in physics classes, particularly focusing on the first 20 elements of the periodic table. The initial ranking highlights hydrogen (Z=1), helium (Z=2), and uranium (Z=92) as frequently discussed elements, although there is debate about the significance of carbon (C) and silicon (Si) in various scientific contexts. Participants emphasize that the relevance of elements varies depending on the subject matter, such as astronomy, life sciences, or nuclear physics. The conversation also touches on the importance of transition metals in structural alloys and the role of calcium (Ca) in biological processes. Recommendations include using a periodic table for reference and acknowledging the diverse applications and discussions surrounding different elements in educational settings.
CPW
Messages
51
Reaction score
30
My child is learning the periodic table for science class, memorizing elements 1 - 20. Middle school.
While I assisted, I mused on the elements and on which are discussed most in physics classes.
Here is my ranking of the top three:
1. Z=1
2. Z=2
3. Z=92

Do you agree?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Somehow I think carbon is much more important than helium or uranium. The top four are probably CHON - the stuff of life.
 
The question isn't which are important, it's which get talked about in physics classes.
 
  • Like
Likes CPW
CPW said:
Here is my ranking of the top three:
1. Z=1
2. Z=2
3. Z=92

Do you agree?
You missed Si.
 
  • Like
Likes collinsmark, Vanadium 50, hutchphd and 1 other person
I don't recall any elements getting discussed in a mechanics class. Hydrogen and helium is more an astronomy thing. I suppose uranium might come up if the atomic bomb were discussed.
 
  • Like
Likes Astronuc
CPW said:
My child is learning the periodic table for science class, memorizing elements 1 - 20. Middle school.
While I assisted, I mused on the elements and on which are discussed most in physics classes.
Here is my ranking of the top three:
1. Z=1
2. Z=2
3. Z=92

Do you agree?
The element discussed depends on the subject at hand. Hydrogen (proton) is perhaps discussed in terms of it's simplicity. In EM/QM/Astronomy, one is likely to discuss Lyman, Balmer and Paschen spectral lines. He would be next. If one discusses stars, then H/D and He would be discussed, and C, N, O. Digging deeper, one might get into Li, Be, B as well as C, N, O. Life science related topics would certainly involve H, C, N, O.

If one discusses planets or geological topics, then certainly Al, Si, O, and probably Na, Mg, P, S, Cl as well. If one discusses minerals, crystals, X-ray diffraction, then one might add additional common light elements.

Nuclear science topics, e.g., natural decays series would certainly involve U, but perhaps all elements (and their isotopes from Bi/Pb on up). http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/Nuclear/radser.html

I would recommend printing a copy of the periodic table and posting it in the child's room.
https://www.nist.gov/system/files/documents/2019/12/10/nist_periodictable_july2019.pdf

I have it saved on my computer desktops for quick reference. Note the rows and columns.

Transition elements begin with Scandium (Sc), a rather rare and expensive element, but it is an important alloying element with Al. Note the elements, Ti and V, which are important light elements used in structural alloys. Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni are used in a variety of structural alloys, e.g., steels, stainless steels (predominantly Fe), Ni-based superalloys, Co-based superalloys, . . . Cu is an important conductor, Si and Ge are important for semiconductors, and in fact, SiC is an important structural ceramic and semiconductor.

Edit/update: One could also consider Ca a structural element, a principal component of animal skeletons (bones) and exoskeletons, and limestone CaCO3.

Calcium is the most abundant metal and the fifth-most abundant element in the human body.[5] As electrolytes, calcium ions (Ca2+) play a vital role in the physiological and biochemical processes of organisms and cells: in signal transduction pathways where they act as a second messenger; in neurotransmitter release from neurons; in contraction of all muscle cell types; as cofactors in many enzymes; and in fertilization.[5] Calcium ions outside cells are important for maintaining the potential difference across excitable cell membranes, protein synthesis, and bone formation.
Ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calcium
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes pinball1970, 256bits, CPW and 1 other person
Hornbein said:
Hydrogen and helium is more an astronomy thing.
How can we forget QM?
 
  • Like
Likes robphy and hutchphd
I just looked at Halliday, Resnick and Walker, 9th edition. From the index, including applications:

  • Hydrogen: 47 references.(excluding references to protons)
  • Helium: 11 (including alpha particles)
  • Carbon: 17 (includes allotropic forms)
  • Oxygen: 15 (includes oxides, excludes water)
  • Neon: 4
  • Sodium: 8
  • Aluminum: 2
  • Silicon: 4
  • Iron: 14 (includes steel)
  • Copper: 36
  • Gold: 3
  • Mercury: 4
  • Lead: 7
  • Radon: 2
  • Uranium: 42
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes CPW, berkeman and Astronuc
Vanadium 50 said:
Sodium: 8
Is chlorine (Cl) mentioned in conjunction with Na, as in NaCl?

I looked for an index for Halliday, Resnick and Walker, 9th edition on line, but I could not find one, just TOC.
 
  • #10
How about the "element of surprise" ??

As in my favorite question: "is that going to be on the test"?

/
 
  • Haha
Likes pinball1970
  • #11
Astronuc said:
The element discussed depends on the subject at hand ...
That is a CliffsNotes summary.:smile:

Although,
Astronuc said:
He/She/They would be next.
is more acceptable in some classrooms
 
Back
Top