My experience in learning mathematics...opinions?

  • Thread starter Kilo Vectors
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Experience
In summary, the conversation discusses the various ways that mathematics is taught and presented, and the struggle to fully understand the concepts being taught. The speakers also touch on the relationship between mathematics and philosophy, and the importance of reading textbooks and supplementary materials to gain a deeper understanding. They also mention their own personal struggles with learning math and ask for book recommendations.
  • #1
Kilo Vectors
85
16
Hello

I have noticed that there are hundreds of ways of teaching one theorem/concept in maths, often very complicated with pure math terminology the likes of which I find an absolute nightmare! to very basic and just using similies. It always "blows my mind" that there are so many different ways the mathematics is taught and presented across the vast material for learning that I use. It does not help that I come from a school where we were taught to be robots and not mathematicians. We were never taught what a derivative actually is (how it is presented in the textbooks) but just taught how to do it. We were drilled into solving thousands of functions of trigonometry but never touched upon what their origins or meaning were.anyway.its just unbelievable how many ways of teaching one concept exist.

Has anyone else noticed this? I wish there was one book which I could stick to, but there really won't ever be. I am pretty shallow in my knowledge and don't practice it enough, but I feel like I am learning.

Re: the significance of my school experience, well I really feel lost sometimes as I know I truly don't understand what I am doing. This troubles me, as I don't trust anything which I don't completely understand. This is what motivates me to learn math inside out..I know how to derivate functions and trigonometric identikits but the real reasons and why is missing? We were never taught that..Guess it really is upto the student.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Mathematics has been closely related to philosophy for centuries. And in a way it is still. The fact that physics and engineering uses mathematics as their language kind of conceals this fact. Mathematics in its core is a language about abstractly defined objects. There are no circles in the real world, smooth motions or real numbers. The real world is highly discreet stuff: atoms. Nevertheless mathematical concepts prove very suitable to handle the world around us. I've read several times here on PF that physics is the art of finding models for physical phenomena that allow us to make descriptions about what we know and even more important predictions about what we don't know yet. These models have to be formulated in some language and mathematics turned out to be more precise than words. The more you go back in time the more words you will find in texts about physics or mathematics. The common usage of logical expressions and formulas is a quite new way to present knowledge.
So a main part about these fields is about learning a language and developing a feeling for what is meant by those special words used. It can still lead you into traps for sometimes terms are used as well in common English language as well as in science, usually not meaning the same thing.

There is one question that can guide you through all obstacles ahead: Why?

The different concepts of presenting mathematical results are probably attempts to narrow the gap between those abstract models and everyday experiences. Once you've seen how often, e.g. ##π## or ##e## naturally occur in complete different contexts it won't matter how they have been introduced or defined in the first place. They are abstract bricks that apply to many (colloquial language!) buildings.
 
  • Like
Likes mechpeac and Kilo Vectors
  • #3
What's stopping you from reading the textbook? Lectures are no replacement to reading the assigned/supplementary texts.
 
  • Like
Likes mathwonk and Kilo Vectors
  • #4
Because when you are in the beggining of the course you probably couldn't understand what is the real definition of the thing, thia is why a E.M course is taught with different levels of deepness, for a freshman in college the E.M is nothing compared to a graduate E.M, the last is much more deep, is so for mathematics, if you want to know what a derivative really is and even more, go to real analysis, if you want to know more about the propertries of objects in space, go for topology, and so on..
 
  • Like
Likes Kilo Vectors
  • #5
fresh_42 said:
Mathematics has been closely related to philosophy for centuries. And in a way it is still. The fact that physics and engineering uses mathematics as their language kind of conceals this fact. Mathematics in its core is a language about abstractly defined objects. There are no circles in the real world, smooth motions or real numbers.
The different concepts of presenting mathematical results are probably attempts to narrow the gap between those abstract models and everyday experiences. Once you've seen how often, e.g. ##π## or ##e## naturally occur in complete different contexts it won't matter how they have been introduced or defined in the first place. They are abstract bricks that apply to many (colloquial language!) buildings.
Student100 said:
What's stopping you from reading the textbook? Lectures are no replacement to reading the assigned/supplementary texts.

Andreol263 said:
Because when you are in the beggining of the course you probably couldn't understand what is the real definition of the thing, thia is why a E.M course is taught with different levels of deepness, for a freshman in college the E.M is nothing compared to a graduate E.M, the last is much more deep, is so for mathematics, if you want to know what a derivative really is and even more, go to real analysis, if you want to know more about the propertries of objects in space, go for topology, and so on..
Yes, I hope to one day completely understand them. I do read the book but I have just really started 1 month ago. I use the schaums outlines for basic knowledge, but I find it a hurried introduction. So I use other books. I had got accepted into a Bsc physics program back home but because of my poor mathematics I had to abandon it. Any books you would be able to recommend? I just got comfortable with the basic theory of numbers and properties of number sets. Not once during school were we taught that numbers are such an abstract concept. I don't think I am intelligent enough naturally to pick up this stuff fast.

Basically I have a collection of books but going through each slowly, is not a good strategy..I find it difficult to know what is the ideal time to really learn concepts like this?
 
Last edited:

1. How important is it to have a positive attitude when learning mathematics?

Having a positive attitude towards learning mathematics is crucial. It can greatly impact your motivation, confidence, and overall success in the subject. A positive attitude can help you overcome challenges and see mistakes as opportunities for growth.

2. What are some effective strategies for understanding and retaining mathematical concepts?

One effective strategy is to practice regularly and consistently. This allows you to reinforce your understanding and retain information in the long term. Additionally, breaking down complex concepts into smaller, more manageable parts can make them easier to understand.

3. How can I overcome my fear of making mistakes in math?

Making mistakes is a natural part of the learning process, and it is important to not let fear hold you back. One way to overcome this fear is to embrace it as a learning opportunity. Reflect on your mistakes and use them to improve your understanding and approach to problem-solving.

4. What are some common misconceptions about learning mathematics?

One common misconception is that you have to be naturally good at math to succeed. In reality, anyone can improve their math skills with practice and dedication. Another misconception is that there is only one correct way to solve a math problem. There are often multiple approaches to a problem, so don't be afraid to try different methods.

5. How can I make math more enjoyable and engaging?

One way to make math more enjoyable is to find real-world applications of the concepts you are learning. This can help you see the relevance and practicality of math in everyday life. Another way is to work with others, whether it be through group study sessions or online discussions. Collaboration can make learning math more fun and interactive.

Similar threads

Replies
5
Views
540
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
1
Views
824
Replies
7
Views
683
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
758
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
14
Views
551
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
890
  • STEM Academic Advising
2
Replies
49
Views
3K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
8
Views
715
Back
Top