I Newton's 3rd law and ether in space

  • I
  • Thread starter Thread starter appot89
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Ether Law Space
AI Thread Summary
Newton's 3rd law suggests that for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction, which some argue implies that the mass of space, or ether, between objects should be zero. This leads to the conclusion that ether does not exist. However, the validity of this argument is debated, with some participants expressing skepticism about the source of the claim. There is also mention of electromagnetic energy's role in conservation laws, indicating that it should be considered in discussions about momentum and force. The conversation reflects a mix of acceptance and doubt regarding the interpretation of Newton's laws in relation to ether.
appot89
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
TL;DR Summary
Hey everyone,

I've read in an article that newton's 3rd law proves that there is no ether in space. Why is that?
Hey everyone,

I've read in an article that Newton's 3rd law proves that there is no ether in space. It says, according to Newton's 3rd law, the mass of the space between objects should be 0; then, ether does not actually exist.
Could you please explain to me why Newton's 3rd law imply that the mass of ether should be zero?
https://lockhaven.edu/~dsimanek/cutting/3rdlaw.htm (please check number 6)
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
appot89 said:
the mass of the space between objects should be 0;

Electromagnetic energy is stored in space as (ED+BH)/2. I have not heard of its influence to the Newton's third law though we live in the world of electromagnetic technology, e.g. wifi. In this case electromagnetic energy and momentum should be included into account of their conservations in system, of course.
 
appot89 said:
Summary:: Hey everyone,

I've read in an article that Newton's 3rd law proves that there is no ether in space. Why is that?

Hey everyone,

I've read in an article that Newton's 3rd law proves that there is no ether in space. It says, according to Newton's 3rd law, the mass of the space between objects should be 0; then, ether does not actually exist.
Could you please explain to me why Newton's 3rd law imply that the mass of ether should be zero?
https://lockhaven.edu/~dsimanek/cutting/3rdlaw.htm (please check number 6)
I think that webpage is not very good at all. I would ignore what it says.
 
Agreed. I find the page highly questionable.

Edit: The rest of the site seems to be okay, so I would take a further look before casting judgment on the whole site. But I only did a quick peruse, not an in-depth look.
 
  • Like
Likes Ibix, Delta2 and PeroK
Is a homemade radio telescope realistic? There seems to be a confluence of multiple technologies that makes the situation better than when I was a wee lad: software-defined radio (SDR), the easy availability of satellite dishes, surveillance drives, and fast CPUs. Let's take a step back - it is trivial to see the sun in radio. An old analog TV, a set of "rabbit ears" antenna, and you're good to go. Point the antenna at the sun (i.e. the ears are perpendicular to it) and there is...
3I/ATLAS, also known as C/2025 N1 (ATLAS) and formerly designated as A11pl3Z, is an iinterstellar comet. It was discovered by the Asteroid Terrestrial-impact Last Alert System (ATLAS) station at Río Hurtado, Chile on 1 July 2025. Note: it was mentioned (as A11pl3Z) by DaveE in a new member's introductory thread. https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/brian-cox-lead-me-here.1081670/post-7274146 https://earthsky.org/space/new-interstellar-object-candidate-heading-toward-the-sun-a11pl3z/ One...
Back
Top