Opamp's stabilty in positive feedback

In summary, the mobile app simulation appears to be at fault for the incorrect behavior of the two circuits. The positive feedback circuit does not look right, and the current balances seem off.
  • #1
16
0
sw8sB.jpg

i simulated the circuits in an mobile app. below is another circuit with negative feedback
w4bbe.jpg

i understand how the second circuit works(-ve feedback) but the first circuit... here is how the -ve feedback works(i think) we apply 1 volt to inverting input the output keeps falling(since the input is given to inverting input) from 0V and as it approaches -1V the inverting input becomes 0V(approx) and becomes virtual ground.now the system is stable but in postive feedback circuit (the first one) the input is positive and so is the output when we feed it back the input only becomes more high and must take the output to +ve saturation but as you can see the simulator is not in agreement with it... is it the simulator fault or is my explanation ?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #2
The positive feedback simulation looks wrong. Did you give it initial conditions? Or did the simulator somehow start with the 1V input to its + input and come up with those current values? The voltage at the + input will not be near 0V. It will start at 1V and then get higher as the output pegs up near the + supply input for the opamp. What opamp model are you using?
 
  • #3
dushyanth said:
is it the simulator fault or is my explanation ?

at first glance the simulation is at fault. Nobody would build that circuit with any hope of its working as an amplifier.

There does exist a phenomenon called "Latchup"
wherein an op-amp that's overdriven, as yours would soon be, reverses the sense of an input because some internal transistor saturates.
That causes the circuit to drive to one limit and stay, ie latch-up.

I daresay nowadays most opamps are "latchup-proof " but in the 709 days we had to watch out for it.

Also, the 709 could latch up whenever the input CM voltage rose high enough to saturate the input stage. And, excessive differential input voltages could blow out the input transistors. Although savvy users could work around these 709 application quirks, it sometimes took extra parts to do it. So, in one sense the above use-related issues served as a general lesson towards the necessity of bullet-proofing an IC op amp. against various application stresses.
http://www.elektropage.com/default.asp?tid=177

That's doubtless why Berkeman asked what opamp you used. Maybe your simulation program is realistic enough to catch that quirk.
 
  • #4
There is something wrong with the precision. In order to get -1V out of the inverting opamp you need 10uV on the input. It shows that on the non-inverting opamp, but not on the inverting example.

It seems to be a 100KV/V voltage controlled voltage source, not an opamp model.

So how does 100K times 0 give -1V?

Also, the currents at the positive node of the positive feedback example do not balance out. There is 1V + 10uV across one resistor and 1V -10uV across the other.

You can mess with pspice so it doesn't converge properly. Or, you can misinterpret what you are seeing and draw it incorrectly.
 
  • #5
dushyanth said:
sw8sB.jpg

i simulated the circuits in an mobile app. below is another circuit with negative feedback
w4bbe.jpg
What has happened to Kirchoff's Law for currents in/out OP amp here?
 

What is an opamp?

An opamp, short for operational amplifier, is an electronic component that amplifies the difference between two input voltages and outputs the result.

How does positive feedback affect the stability of an opamp?

Positive feedback can cause an opamp to become unstable, leading to oscillations or unexpected behavior. This is because positive feedback increases the gain of the opamp, amplifying any noise or disturbances in the input signal.

What is the purpose of using positive feedback in opamps?

Positive feedback is used in opamps to create oscillators or to increase the gain of the opamp in certain applications. It can also be used to introduce hysteresis, which is useful in applications like Schmitt triggers.

How can the stability of an opamp in positive feedback be improved?

To improve stability, a compensation network can be added to the opamp circuit. This network introduces additional phase shift to counteract the positive feedback and stabilize the opamp. Additionally, proper layout and decoupling techniques can also help improve stability.

Are there any drawbacks to using positive feedback in opamps?

One of the main drawbacks of using positive feedback is the potential for instability, which can lead to unpredictable behavior and affect the accuracy of the opamp. It also requires careful design and consideration of the circuit layout, which can add complexity and cost to the overall system.

Suggested for: Opamp's stabilty in positive feedback

Replies
20
Views
878
Replies
1
Views
892
Replies
11
Views
3K
Replies
17
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
958
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
801
Back
Top