P-V Diagram: Computing Work and Determining Sign of Work

2 replies · 4K views · last reply
Saladsamurai
Messages
3,009
Reaction score
7

Homework Statement


Photo of a textbook page showing problem 2.27 from Chapter 2, Energy and the First Law of Thermodynamics: a gas is compressed from V1 = 0.3 m^3, p1 = 1 bar to V2 = 0.1 m^3, p2 = 3 bar with linear pressure-volume relation; find the work in kJ. Below is blank grid paper.


I have plotted the info as such

Handwritten P-V diagram on grid paper for problem 2.27: V1 = .3 m^3 at p1 = 1 bar = 10^5 N/m^2 to V2 = .1 m^3 at p2 = 3 bar = 3(10^5) N/m^2; a line runs from (1, .3) to (3, .1) with the area below shaded, and W = -A_triangle + A_rectangle is written below.


I can compute the work by adding the area of the triangle to the area of the rectangle, but my question is is all of this work negative? It is compressed so I am assuming it is?
 
Last edited:
Hi Saladsamurai,

Is your book asking for the work done by the gas, or the work done on the gas?
 
Saladsamurai said:

Homework Statement


Photo of a printed textbook page showing Chapter 2 problem 2.27: a gas is compressed from V1 = 0.3 m³, p1 = 1 bar to V2 = 0.1 m³, p2 = 3 bar, with pressure and volume linearly related; find the work in kJ, above a blank grid-paper notebook page.


I have plotted the info as such

Handwritten P-V diagram on grid paper for problem 2.27: V1 = .3 m^3, p1 = 1 bar = 10^5 N/m^2 to V2 = .1 m^3, p2 = 3 bar = 3(10^5) N/m^2. Shaded triangle under a straight line from (1, .3) to (3, .1) on V versus P axes, with W = -A + A written below.


I can compute the work by adding the area of the triangle to the area of the rectangle, but my question is is all of this work negative? It is compressed so I am assuming it is?

I can't see your diagram while I'm at work, however, based on what you wrote if the dV is negative, then the boundary work will be negative. If the dV is positive, then the boundary work is positive. Remember that P is absolute pressure and is thus always positive.

[tex]W_b = \int_1^2 PdV[/tex]

Like alphysicist eluded to, it may be written as a positive value based on the convention taken.

CS