Parameters for Root Locus Method using Lead Compensator

2 replies · 5K views · last reply
hurliehoo
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Hi everyone, I would please like some suggestions regarding where my error is, designing a lead compensator with the root locus method for a unity feedback control system where G = [12.5] / [2.5 1 2500]. I want to set the overshoot zeta = 0.5 for an overshoot of 16%, and settling time Ts = 0.06s.

Using these parameters I get a desired pole at -66.665 + j115.467.

I think I understand the application of the root-locus method, ie summing the angles of the poles and zeros with the new pole etc, and I've tried it with a couple of different values for compensator poles and zeros using these parameters (eg a = 66.665, b = 290.65). I always get the correct Ts, but an overshoot of 46% instead of 16%.
 
Last edited:
how are you factoring in the overshoot into your calculation for the new poles?
 
swraman said:
how are you factoring in the overshoot into your calculation for the new poles?

Hi, thanks for the reply.

Basically I'm using this formula to find roots at

Handwritten or typeset equation for closed-loop pole location: s1,2 = -zeta*wn ± j*wn*sqrt(1 - zeta^2).


and Ts = 4 / ( zeta * w(0) ) = 0.06

using w(0) = 133.33 because zeta = 0.5 for a 16% overshoot due to

Small equation: M = e raised to the power of minus pi times zeta over the square root of one minus zeta squared, with zeta in the exponent numerator and denominator.


Then I calculate the angle to the desired pole at -66.665 + j115.467 from the first singularity at -0.2+j31.362 (original system) = -128.41

From the second singularity -0.2-j31.362 = -114.32

This gives a total of -242.73. It needs to adjust by +62.73 to get an odd multiple of 180. I then add for example a zero at -66.665 on the real axis, to add 90.

-242.73 + 90 = -152.73 so a pole of angle 27.27 will produce an odd multiple of 180. Putting a pole at -290.65 on the real axis does this.

... At least I think it should do ... the system doesn't give an overshoot anywhere near 16% though, and I can't understand why.
 
Last edited: