Particle Collision: Max Deflection of 2kg Part

Click For Summary

Homework Help Overview

The discussion revolves around a particle collision problem involving a 2kg particle and a 4kg particle, focusing on determining the maximum deflection of the 2kg particle after an elastic collision. The context includes concepts from mechanics, specifically momentum and energy conservation during collisions.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory, Assumption checking, Problem interpretation

Approaches and Questions Raised

  • Participants suggest analyzing the collision in the center of momentum frame to simplify the problem. There are discussions about the number of variables and equations involved, with some questioning whether there is a more straightforward method to arrive at a solution.

Discussion Status

Guidance has been offered regarding the use of the center of momentum frame, and participants are exploring different interpretations of the problem. Some express uncertainty about the complexity of the equations derived from conservation laws, while others emphasize the need to show work for further assistance.

Contextual Notes

There is a mention of the problem being treated as homework, despite one participant indicating it is from a course book. Participants are reminded to adhere to forum rules regarding homework help submissions.

lawrence1234
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
A particle of mass 2kg moving with speed 6m/s collides ellastically with another particle of mass 4kg traveling in same direction with a speed of 2m/s. Find max deflection of 2kg particle?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Hi lawrence1234. Welcome to the forum.

For homework help you need to put this into the template. Also, you need to show that you have made some effort to solve your own problem. People here are not supposed to just do your homework for you. But I will give you some hints.

Problems of this nature are usually easier to solve if you look at the collision in the centre of momentum frame. In that frame the two particles will have equal but opposite momentum. In that frame an elastic collision is very simple. The particles come in with the same-but-opposite-sign momentum. They go out with same-but-opposite-sign momentum but in some other direction. But in this problem you don't know the angle they go out at. So you include this angle as a variable.

Then you transform the after-collision situation back to the lab frame and work out the possible angles the 2 kg particle could take. And find the maximum deflection.
 
DEvens said:
Hi lawrence1234. Welcome to the forum.

For homework help you need to put this into the template. Also, you need to show that you have made some effort to solve your own problem. People here are not supposed to just do your homework for you. But I will give you some hints.

Problems of this nature are usually easier to solve if you look at the collision in the centre of momentum frame. In that frame the two particles will have equal but opposite momentum. In that frame an elastic collision is very simple. The particles come in with the same-but-opposite-sign momentum. They go out with same-but-opposite-sign momentum but in some other direction. But in this problem you don't know the angle they go out at. So you include this angle as a variable.

Then you transform the after-collision situation back to the lab frame and work out the possible angles the 2 kg particle could take. And find the maximum deflection.
 
DEvens said:
Hi lawrence1234. Welcome to the forum.

For homework help you need to put this into the template. Also, you need to show that you have made some effort to solve your own problem. People here are not supposed to just do your homework for you. But I will give you some hints.

Problems of this nature are usually easier to solve if you look at the collision in the centre of momentum frame. In that frame the two particles will have equal but opposite momentum. In that frame an elastic collision is very simple. The particles come in with the same-but-opposite-sign momentum. They go out with same-but-opposite-sign momentum but in some other direction. But in this problem you don't know the angle they go out at. So you include this angle as a variable.

Then you transform the after-collision situation back to the lab frame and work out the possible angles the 2 kg particle could take. And find the maximum deflection.
yeah srry i
DEvens said:
Hi lawrence1234. Welcome to the forum.

For homework help you need to put this into the template. Also, you need to show that you have made some effort to solve your own problem. People here are not supposed to just do your homework for you. But I will give you some hints.

Problems of this nature are usually easier to solve if you look at the collision in the centre of momentum frame. In that frame the two particles will have equal but opposite momentum. In that frame an elastic collision is very simple. The particles come in with the same-but-opposite-sign momentum. They go out with same-but-opposite-sign momentum but in some other direction. But in this problem you don't know the angle they go out at. So you include this angle as a variable.

Then you transform the after-collision situation back to the lab frame and work out the possible angles the 2 kg particle could take. And find the maximum deflection.
yeah srry I am new here ill post my work next time i did it correctly though acc to ur hints ill check again if i hve any problem thx
 
lawrence1234 said:
yeah srry i
im getting 4 variables here and 4 equations here by conserviing momentum and energy in x and y direction
is there any other easier way to solve it
becoz its a multiple choice single correct answer it should not be that lenghty
 
yeah and this was not homework srry i just had a doubt from my cource book
 
Did you do it the way I said? If you do then you don't get four variables, you get one. The angle will be the only variable left over.

If you want more help, please show your work.
 
k ill try it again
 
lawrence1234 said:
yeah and this was not homework srry i just had a doubt from my cource book

We treat all schoolwork-type questions as homework here. Next time you start a schoolwork thread, use the Homework Help Template and fill out the sections on the Relevant Equations and show your Attempt at a Solution. That's in the PF rules (see Info at the top of the page).
 

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
1K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
4K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
1K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
3K