Pixel pitch, Airy disk diameter and maximum aperture

5 replies · 16K views · last reply
D_K
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Hi,
How to determine a threshold aperture, at which the diffraction begins to limit resolution of the sensor ? Which situation reflects that point:

1) Airy disk diameter / 2 = 2 x pixel pitch
http://www.outbackphoto.com/dp_essentials/dp_essentials_02/essay.html"
(third pixel detects the dark gap between two points)

2) Airy disk diameter / 2 = 1 x pixel pitch

3) Airy disk diameter = pixel pitch
it seems that http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airy_disk" , and many webpages

#1 and #2 just meet the http://books.google.pl/books?id=5Yn...nd digital imaging By R. E. Jacobson&f=false", #3 is far further.

Three stacked diagrams of two Airy disk intensity curves, blue and red, with pixel boxes below: top shows Airy disk diameter / 2 equal to 2 x pixel pitch, middle shows it equal to 1 x pixel pitch, bottom shows Airy disk diameter equal to 1 x pixel pitch.


And how to draw such plot:
http://books.google.pl/books?id=5Yn...and digital imaging By R. E. Jacobson&f=false
(Page 80, Fig 6.11)
using software like http://www.padowan.dk/graph/" or eventually Google Charts ? I mean simplified function equation or equations.

Thanks
 
Attachments
  • Three stacked diagrams of two Airy disk intensity curves, one blue and one red, over grey pixel boxes. Top: Airy disk diameter / 2 spans two pixel pitches. Middle: the same spacing spans one pixel pitch. Bottom: Airy disk diameter spans one pixel pitch.
    airy-disk.gif
    17.6 KB · Views: 1,153
Last edited by a moderator:
Are you asking how the Airy disk radius relates to the lens aperture and focal length? That's straightforward: the radius (in microns) can be estimated as r = 0.6*(f-number), where the f-number is given by F/D, where F is the focal length and D the entrance pupil diameter.

Equivalently, this is given by r = 0.3/NA, where NA is the numerical aperture of the lens.

You are very much correct that the Airy disk should be matched to the pixel size for optimized imaging performance.
 
No, how maximum aperture (and coresponding Airy disk radius or diameter) relates to the pixel pitch:

2 * P = D / 2 or
P = D / 2 or
P = D

where
D – Airy disk diameter
P – pixel pitch

How to calculate the aperture, at which making the pixels of the image sensor smaller does not increase image resolution any more, because the diffraction begins to limit the resolution (Airy disk is to large, but how much, how it's diameter or radius relates to the pixel pitch).

And why did you use equations other then these:

r = D / 2 = 1.22 * wavelength * y * K / f
for infinity y = f -->
r = D / 2 = 1.22 * wavelength * K

where
r - Airy disk radius
D - Airy disk diameter
y - picture distance
f - focal length
K - f-number (entrance pupil diameter d = f / K)

Where is 0.6 derived from and why your equation lacks the wavenlength ?

Regarding the second question I made in the middletime plots based on Gaussian approximation from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airy_disk#Approximation_using_a_Gaussian_profile", but not sure if correct:

Plot of normalized PSF amplitude against radial coord. in units of λ·Fnum: red and blue Gaussian peaks at 0 and about 1.22, with a green sum curve showing two overlapping peaks and a dip between them.


wavelength = 550 nm
f-number = 8

red curve:
1 * exp(-(x * (550 * 8)) ^ 2 / (2 * (0.44 * 550 * 8) ^ 2))

blue curve:
1 * exp(-((x - 1.22) * (550 * 8)) ^ 2 / (2 * (0.44 * 550 * 8) ^ 2))

blue curve + red curve (--> green curve)
1 * exp(-(x * (550 * 8)) ^ 2 / (2 * (0.44 * 550 * 8) ^ 2)) + 1 * exp(-((x - 1.22) * (550 * 8)) ^ 2 / (2 * (0.44 * 550 * 8) ^ 2))

And this is only approximation, without those secondary "hills".

(airy-disk.zip contains the airy-disk.grf file for Graph).
 
Attachments
  • airy-disk.zip
    airy-disk.zip
    702 bytes · Views: 399
  • Graph of normalized PSF amplitude against radial coord. (in units of 2 * Fnum): a red Gaussian peak at 0 and a blue peak at about 1.2, with their green sum showing a dip between them.
    airy-disk-2.gif
    14 KB · Views: 1,130
Last edited by a moderator:
D_K said:
No, how maximum aperture (and coresponding Airy disk radius or diameter) relates to the pixel pitch:

<snip>
How to calculate the aperture, at which making the pixels of the image sensor smaller does not increase image resolution any more, because the diffraction begins to limit the resolution (Airy disk is to large, but how much, how it's diameter or radius relates to the pixel pitch).

The truth is, in reality it doesn't much matter which you choose for at least three reasons:
1) the actual PSF is almost always larger than an Airy disk
2) there's no single metric for resolution
3) using non-shift-invariant detectors (pixels) negates a lot of linear systems analysis. One practical issue is aliasing- the periodicity of the pixel array literally interferes with the periodicity in the image.

So, as a rule of thumb, if your pixel is half the size of a PSF, you are fully taking advantage of the optical system.

D_K said:
And why did you use equations other then these:
<snip>

Where is 0.6 derived from and why your equation lacks the wavenlength ?

Sorry- I simply set the wavelength to 0.5 microns (green light), and 1.22*0.5 = 0.6. If your system is not operating in the visible, then your numbers will be substantially different.
 
Andy Resnick said:
using non-shift-invariant detectors (pixels) negates a lot of linear systems analysis.
This is the basic problem. But they are so classical, being in use from tens of years or even longer ...
 
D_K said:
This is the basic problem. But they are so classical, being in use from tens of years or even longer ...

I'm not sure what you mean- the analysis of sampled imaging systems is fairly mature:

http://spie.org/x648.html?product_id=853462
http://www.opticsinfobase.org/abstract.cfm?URI=ao-36-29-7307
http://books.google.com/books?id=f3...epage&q="sampled imaging systems" PSF&f=false

and section 2.5 of this:

http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&sour...sg=AFQjCNEfV1MBFx3gSbA2tALKannEHimy8Q&cad=rja