Please Restore My Post: Forum Rules & Free Speech

  • Thread starter Thread starter alteredmind
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on a user's request to restore a deleted post about "hot female scientists," arguing it did not violate forum rules and questioning the concept of free speech. Responses clarify that free speech protects against government action, not private forum rules, and that the forum aims to maintain a respectful environment. The moderators emphasize that the topic is inappropriate and not aligned with the forum's spirit. The user expresses confusion about the forum's governance and its stance on such discussions. Ultimately, the forum is a private domain with specific guidelines for civil discourse.
alteredmind
Messages
13
Reaction score
0
please restore my post, I don't think I broke any forum rules, what ever happened to free speech
 
Physics news on Phys.org
alteredmind said:
please restore my post, I don't think I broke any forum rules, what ever happened to free speech

Free speech is the concept that the government will not imprison or fine you for anything you say. You have not been imprisoned or fined for your posts, so the concept of free speech has not been violated.

On the other hand, if you go to somebody his house and start insulting him (for example), then that person has every right to put you out of his house. He can ask you to leave any time. This does not violate your free speech since the government does not take any repressive action.

Another example, if you insult your girlfriend, then she has every right to break up with you. This again does not violate your right on free speech. So as you see, the right on free speech protects you from the government, but not from the consequences of whatever you say. The consequences can be getting your posts deleted or getting various people to hate you.

As for your specific post on this forum that has been deleted. We wish not to have a discussion on "hot female scientists". It goes against the spirit of this forum.
 
well, I supposed I pissed off a few people but I had no intention whatsoever to piss off anyone, I just wanted to have some fun. saying "hot female sicentists" goes against the ehem "spirit" of this forum makes me wonder if this forum is really run bye scientists.
 
alteredmind said:
well, I supposed I pissed off a few people but I had no intention whatsoever to piss off anyone, I just wanted to have some fun. saying "hot female sicentists" goes against the ehem "spirit" of this forum makes me wonder if this forum is really run bye scientists.

What is the connection between "not wishing to discuss hot female scientists" and "the forum is not run by scientists"? Do you claim that every scientist likes to discuss "hot female scientists"?
 
I think I'm not updated about your post. What was your free speech about?
 
micromass said:
What is the connection between "not wishing to discuss hot female scientists" and "the forum is not run by scientists"? Do you claim that every scientist likes to discuss "hot female scientists"?
no

jmneutr0nn3 said:
I think I'm not updated about your post. What was your free speech about?

I forget now
 
alteredmind said:
no

OK, so then how exactly did you come to the conclusion that this forum is not run by scientists?
 
jmneutr0nn3 said:
I think I'm not updated about your post. What was your free speech about?

Topic title " ;)"

And the OP was this, as I remember:

"Let's play a game on hot female scientists mmmmm :smile:"
I don't remember well, but it was like that.
 
This forum isn't intended to be perverted, I'm afraid. Not even in the Fun and Games section.

As for "free speech", if you actually knew anything about the Constitution, you'd know that "free speech" refers to a prohibition of government restriction of speech, and it's unfortunate, but we're not the government.

Yet.
 
  • #10
alteredmind said:
saying "hot female sicentists" goes against the ehem "spirit" of this forum makes me wonder if this forum is really run bye scientists.

Being disrespectful to fellow scientists doesn't make one a scientist.
 
  • #11
alteredmind said:
well, I supposed I pissed off a few people but I had no intention whatsoever to piss off anyone, I just wanted to have some fun. saying "hot female sicentists" goes against the ehem "spirit" of this forum makes me wonder if this forum is really run bye scientists.

Are you sure you weren't looking for 4chan or tumblr and accidentally ended up at physics forums?
 
  • #12
To the OP: like someone has already stated, the concept of free speech is at a public environment. While I don't agree with everything at physicsforums.com, the servers and website is a private domain. This website doesn't charge you for anything and provides a domain for learning and civil discussions within the context of a certain set of rules.
 
  • #13
free_speech.png
 
  • #14
I think you've gotten a proper explanation. Closing this thread now. Thanks!
 

Similar threads

Replies
25
Views
3K
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
66
Views
5K
Replies
25
Views
3K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Back
Top