Point where magnetic field cancels between two current carrying wires.

7 replies · 3K views · last reply
SherlockOhms
Messages
309
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Problem statement along with relevant diagram attached with picture below.

Homework Equations


The Biot-Savart Law for a long current carrying wire.
B = (μ)(I)/2(pi)(d)
Where d is the perpendicular distance between the wire and the point at which the field is being calculated. μ is the permeability of free space.

The Attempt at a Solution


(a) Point at which field is null:
Net magnetic field = 0.
Thus, the sum of the magnetic fields at a certain point is 0. (One will point into the page and one will point out of the page)
Thus:
Bnet = 0 ⇔ (μ)(I1)/2(pi)(ρ) = (μ)(I1/2)/2(pi)(d - ρ)
Calculate ρ. I think it works out to be 2d/3.
Could someone tell me if this is correct?
Also, for part (b) what adjustment should be made? Assuming I did (a) correctly. Thanks.
 
Phone screenshot of a printed problem page showing two diagrams of parallel wires labelled I1 and I2 separated by distance d, with a point marked rho; the text poses a magnetic field cancellation question for currents in the same and opposite directions.
 
DAPOS said:
Bnet = 0 ⇔ (μ)(I1)/2(pi)(ρ) = (μ)(I1/2)/2(pi)(d - ρ)
Calculate ρ. I think it works out to be 2d/3.
Sounds right.
Also, for part (b) what adjustment should be made?
What change do you think it makes to the field from I2?
 
Will both fields be pointing out of the page (in the positive k) in the region of 0-d?
 
Sorry! I meant into the page. In the negative k.
 
DAPOS said:
Sorry! I meant into the page. In the negative k.

Yes, but I meant, what difference does it make to the equation?
 
Well. instead of having:
(I)(μ)/(2)(pi)(ρ) - (I/2)(μ)/(2)(pi)(d - ρ) = 0

We'll now have:
(I)(μ)/(2)(pi)(ρ) + (I/2)(μ)/(2)(pi)(d - ρ) = 0
I think the answer works out to be ρ = 2d.
 
DAPOS said:
Well. instead of having:
(I)(μ)/(2)(pi)(ρ) - (I/2)(μ)/(2)(pi)(d - ρ) = 0

We'll now have:
(I)(μ)/(2)(pi)(ρ) + (I/2)(μ)/(2)(pi)(d - ρ) = 0
I think the answer works out to be ρ = 2d.
Looks right.