Potential at centre of cylinder

40 replies · 5K views · last reply
Saitama
Messages
4,244
Reaction score
93

Homework Statement


Text problem: a very long hollow metallic cylinder of radius R, a section at theta = 20 degrees kept at constant potential V = 110 V, the rest grounded at 0 V; find the potential Vaxis in volts on the axis (point O).



Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution


I have no idea on this one. I can't understand what happens when some portion of the cylinder is earthed and other is maintained at 110V. The potential of the earthed portion is 0V but how does that even help me? :confused:

Any help is appreciated. Thanks!
 
Attachments
  • Text problem: a very long hollow metallic cylinder of radius R, with a section at theta = 20 degrees held at 110 V and the rest grounded at 0 V; find the potential on the axis at point O in volts.
    ques.jpg
    15.6 KB · Views: 589
  • Circle representing a ring with a 20° arc marked at the centre 0 and radius R; a wire at the top of the arc is labelled V = 110V and a wire at the lower right is connected to ground.
    3057-small_1.png
    6.7 KB · Views: 516
Is this not just a simple application of the superposition of electric potentials?
 
voko said:
Is this not just a simple application of the superposition of electric potentials?
Don't you need to know the charge distributions to do that? The OP is a Dirichlet boundary value problem, no?
 
haruspex said:
Don't you need to know the charge distributions to do that? The OP is a Dirichlet boundary value problem, no?

What is this Dirichlet boundary value problem? :confused:
 
Suppose you choose an imaginary circle of radius r < R lying in a plane perpendicular to the axis of the cylinder and centered on the axis of the cylinder.

Try to show that the integral ∫02π V(r,θ)dθ is independent of the value of r, where the integral is over the circle of radius r and θ is the polar angle.

If you can do that, then you can relate V on the axis to the values of V on the cylinder.
 
Last edited:
TSny said:
Suppose you choose an imaginary circle of radius r < R lying in a plane perpendicular to the axis of the cylinder and centered on the axis of the cylinder.

Try to show that the integral ∫02π V(r,θ)dθ is independent of the value of r, where the integral is over the circle of radius r and θ is the polar angle.

If you can do that, then you can relate V at the center to the values of V on the cylinder.

I understand what you say here but how am I even supposed to find ##V(r,\theta)##? :confused:

I don't even have the charge distribution, only the potential of two portions of cylinder.
 
You don't need to find V(r, θ) in order to show that ∫V(r,θ)dθ is independent of r.

Although not obvious, you can show this by starting with Gauss's law for a closed cylindrical Gaussian surface of radius r as shown. See if you can express the net flux through the surface in terms of an integral of Er, the radial component of the electric field. Then relate Er to V(r,θ) inside the integral.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a large outer cylinder with a smaller solid cylinder inside, coaxial along a vertical centre line; the outer radius is labelled R, the inner cylinder's radius r and its height h.
    Cylinder.png
    2.1 KB · Views: 487
TSny said:
Although not obvious, you can show this by starting with Gauss's law for a closed cylindrical Gaussian surface of radius r as shown. See if you can express the net flux through the surface in terms of an integral of Er, the radial component of the electric field. Then relate Er to V(r,θ) inside the integral.

Flux through the Gaussian surface is ##\phi=E_r\cdot 2\pi rh## but this does not involve any integral. :confused:

I think I cannot consider ##E_r## as constant over the whole Gaussian surface, right?

From Gauss law, ##\phi=\int \vec{E_r}\cdot \vec{dA}##. ##\displaystyle E_r=-\frac{dV}{dr}## but this does not involve ##\theta##. :confused:
 
Pranav-Arora said:
Flux through the Gaussian surface is ##\phi=E_r\cdot 2\pi rh## but this does not involve any integral.

Er cannot be assumed to be constant over the surface. So, can you bring it out of the flux integral?

[EDIT]
## E_r=-\frac{dV}{dr}## but this does not involve ##\theta##.

Since V is a function of r and θ, ∂V/∂r will also be a function of r and θ.
 
Last edited:
TSny said:
Since V is a function of r and θ, ∂V/∂r will also be a function of r and θ.

I don't know how to solve ##dV(r,\theta)/dr##. :confused:
 
You don't need to solve dV/dr. Express the flux integral in terms of ∂V/∂r. The goal is to use the flux integral to show d/dr ∫V(r,θ)dθ = 0, which means ∫V(r,θ)dθ over a circle of radius r is a constant (independent of the size of the circle).
 
Last edited:
TSny said:
You don't need to solve dV/dr. Express the flux integral in terms of ∂V/∂r. The goal is to use the flux integral to show d/dr ∫V(r,θ)dθ = 0, which means ∫V(r,θ)dθ over a circle of radius r is a constant (independent of the size of the circle).

Do I need to simply substitute ##E_r=∂V/∂r##? :confused:

haruspex said:

That's too much mathematics. Is there no easier way to this problem? :confused:
 
haruspex said:
Don't you need to know the charge distributions to do that? The OP is a Dirichlet boundary value problem, no?

Well, the solution to a Dirichlet problem, involving Green's function, is an application of superposition :)

But you are correct in that it is not simple and not direct as my original suggestion implied. I think I misunderstood the problem initially.
 
Last edited:
Pranav-Arora said:
That's too much mathematics. Is there no easier way to this problem? :confused:

This is the standard approach to such problems. Besides, most of mathematics there is not for you do, but merely to follow. If you follow, you will see in one example that most of what needs to be done for this problem is done there, you just need to plug in your data to get the solution.
 
Pranav-Arora said:
Do I need to simply substitute ##E_r=∂V/∂r##?
Yes. What does Gauss' law look like for the chosen Gaussian surface after making the substitution ##E_r=-∂V/∂r##.

That should bring you to within a few simple steps of the answer to the question.
 
TSny said:
Yes. What does Gauss' law look like for the chosen Gaussian surface after making the substitution ##E_r=-∂V/∂r##.

That should bring you to within a few simple steps of the answer to the question.

##\displaystyle \phi=\int -\frac{∂V}{∂r}dA##

But what is ##dA##? :confused:
 
Pranav-Arora said:
##\displaystyle \phi=\int -\frac{∂V}{∂r}dA##

But what is ##dA##? :confused:

What part of the Gaussian surface are you integrating over here?
 
TSny said:
What part of the Gaussian surface are you integrating over here?

Is ##dA=rd\theta dy## where y is the distance of the patch(dA) from the top base of the Gaussian surface? :confused:
 
Attachments
  • Circle with a horizontal diameter drawn through its centre, two dashed radii from the centre at a small angle apart, labelled dθ between them and θ from the horizontal diameter.
    att1.png
    4.2 KB · Views: 532
haruspex said:
Section 3.1.2 of http://teacher.pas.rochester.edu/PHY217/LectureNotes/Chapter3/LectureNotesChapter3.pdf is more accessible, but it merely quotes the result you need (Property 2), doesn't prove it.

Property 2 said:
V has no local maxima or minima; all extremes occur at the boundaries
:confused:
How do I get my answer from this statement? The potential at the boundaries is given, I don't see how can I deduce the potential at axis from this property. :(
 
Pranav-Arora said:
Is ##dA=rd\theta dy## where y is the distance of the patch(dA) from the top base of the Gaussian surface? :confused:

Ok. But you can just use vertical strips of height h.
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of a solid cylinder of radius r and height h sitting coaxially inside a larger cylindrical shell of radius R, with a thin vertical strip of height h highlighted in blue on the inner cylinder.
    Cylinder 2.png
    2.4 KB · Views: 475
TSny said:
Ok. But you can just use vertical strips of height h.

But still I don't know how to solve it after substituting ##dA=rhd\theta##. :frown:
 
Substitute your expression for dA into your flux integral expressed in terms of ∂V/∂r. Remember Gauss told you what the flux must equal.
 
Pranav-Arora said:
:confused:
How do I get my answer from this statement? The potential at the boundaries is given, I don't see how can I deduce the potential at axis from this property. :(
Sorry, I should have written Property 1.
 
haruspex said:
Sorry, I should have written Property 1.

Property 1 states that "The value of V at a point (x, y) is equal to the average value of V around this point...", does this mean ##V_{axis}## is the average of 110 V and 0 V, i.e 55.5 V? :rolleyes:

TSny said:
Substitute your expression for dA into your flux integral expressed in terms of ∂V/∂r. Remember Gauss told you what the flux must equal.

The flux is zero i.e
[tex]\int -\frac{∂V}{∂r}rhd\theta=0[/tex]
But what am I supposed to do with this? :confused:
 
Pranav-Arora said:
Property 1 states that "The value of V at a point (x, y) is equal to the average value of V around this point...", does this mean ##V_{axis}## is the average of 110 V and 0 V, i.e 55.5 V? :rolleyes:

Of course not. Which should be quite obvious to you, provided you read what Property 1 states ENTIRELY.
 
voko said:
Of course not. Which should be quite obvious to you, provided you read what Property 1 states ENTIRELY.

Property 1 involves a surface integral. Can I take V out of the integral? :confused:

I don't know how to evaluate surface integrals. :(
 
Pranav-Arora said:
Property 1 involves a surface integral. Can I take V out of the integral? :confused:

I don't know how to evaluate surface integrals. :(

Property 1 of 3.1.2 does not involve any surface integrals. Please do read carefully what you are given.
 
voko said:
Property 1 of 3.1.2 does not involve any surface integrals. Please do read carefully what you are given.

Woops, I used the wrong term I think. Whatever that integral is called, I don't have any idea about evaluating it. :(

Can I take V out of the integral?