Problem Related to Photons with Mass

11 replies · 3K views · last reply
diffidus
Messages
5
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
I am trying to understand example 13.6 given in the book 'Quantum Field Theory for the Gifted Amateur' by Lancaster and Blundell. The problem is: Consider a massive photon in the rest frame so that P^μ=([m,0,0,0). If we boost the particle in the z direction to P^μ=([E,0,0,p) can we calculate the product of the polarisation vectors:
Relevant Equations
I have included the relevant equations below. I tried multiplying the matrices together but could not get the correct answer. Is there anybody out there that can help?
Before boost we have
Equation: sum over lambda from 1 to 3 of epsilon_lambda mu (m, 0) times epsilon_lambda nu (m, 0) equals the 4 by 4 identity matrix with diagonal entries 0, 1, 1, 1 in the top-left-to-bottom-right order shown.

Then using the Lorentz boost:
Equation for a Lorentz boost matrix: Lambda with indices mu and nu, a function of p, equals 1/m times a 4x4 matrix with entries E_p, 0, 0, |p| in the top row; 0, m, 0, 0; 0, 0, m, 0; |p|, 0, 0, E_p in the bottom row.

I want to calculate:

Equation: sum over lambda from 1 to 3 of epsilon_lambda mu(p) epsilon_lambda nu(p) equals Lambda^rho_mu Lambda^sigma_nu times sum over lambda from 1 to 3 of epsilon_lambda rho(m,0) epsilon_lambda sigma(m,0).

I tried multiplying the matrices together but I never get the stated answer which should be:

Equation: equals 1/m^2 times a 4 by 4 matrix with entries |p|^2, 0, 0, -E_p|p| in the top row; 0, m^2, 0, 0 in the second; 0, 0, m^2, 0 in the third; and -E_p|p|, 0, 0, E_p^2 in the bottom row.
 
I get the stated answer except the minus signs. Just using the result of the previous example:
Three four-component column vectors defining polarization vectors: epsilon_1 = (0,1,0,0), epsilon_2 = (0,0,1,0), and epsilon_3 = (|p|/m, 0, 0, E_p/m), labeled equation 13.30.
 
Hill said:
I get the stated answer except the minus signs. Just using the result of the previous example:
View attachment 338712
Hill

So I think you got your result by using the previous example values for ε as you have said. Then, I assume you carried out the product sum with with λ =1,3. Thanks for this answer, it gets me closer but then there is still the annoying minus signs, which makes me think there must be another subtlety and that worries me.
 
diffidus said:
the annoying minus signs
I think they are a typo.
 
Hill said:
I think they are a typo.
That would be great, but I am not certain since in the book that I refer to, it also gives the product involving εε in terms of a projection operator:
Equation: sum from λ = 1 to 3 of ε_λμ(p) ε_λν(p) equals minus P^T subscript μν, with a period at the end.

and that
Equation: negative P super T, with subscript mu nu, equals negative g subscript mu nu plus p subscript mu times p subscript nu divided by m squared.

When I use this method it gives the matrix including the minus signs. So I am still not confident. Anyhow, thanks for your effort, it is really appreciated.
 
diffidus said:
When I use this method it gives the matrix including the minus signs.
Could you show how it gives the minus signs? I don't see it.
 
Hill said:
Could you show how it gives the minus signs? I don't see it.
Apologies - I looked back at my calculation and it appears that I managed to get a minus sign in there. I have redone the calculation and I now get positive values and so I am now completely on the same page as you. In the matrix quoted in the book - it must be a typo. Thanks very much for your help in solving a frustrating problem.
 
Hill said:
Could you show how it gives the minus signs? I don't see it.
I feel a bit like a bad penny now but I have looked over my calculation and I can now see where the minus signs come from.
The problem is given in terms of a boost in the z-direction:
Four-momentum of a photon written as p^mu = (E_p, 0, 0, p), with components E_p, 0, 0 and p.

From this we get:

Equation: A_μν = sum over λ=1 to 3 of ε_λμ ε_λν = Λ^ρ_μ Λ^σ_ν sum over λ=1 to 3 of ε_λρ(m,0) ε_λσ(m,0) = (1/m²) times a 4x4 matrix with rows (p², 0, 0, −E_p p), (0, m², 0, 0), (0, 0, m², 0), (−E_p p, 0, 0, E_p²).

Which can be calculated independently using:

Equation A_μν = −g_μν + p_μ p_ν / m^2, where g_μν is the metric tensor and p_μ, p_ν are momentum components, divided by mass squared m^2.

Using this second method the minus signs in the A matrix arise since in the projection formula the momentum vectors are covariant and so should be:
Four-momentum vector written as p_mu = (E_p, 0, 0, -p), with components E_p, 0, 0 and -p, shown with a lowered index mu.

So for example:

Equation: A03 = -g03 + (p0 p3)/m^2 = 0 + Ep(-p) = -Ep p

Similarly for A30.
The bad news is this still leaves me with the original problem! The good news, however, is that I think I have spotted the issue.

In the original problem equation 13.29 gives the boost matrix as (multiplied by 1/m):

Matrix Λ with upper index mu and lower index nu: 4x4 array with E_p, 0, 0, p in the first row; 0, m, 0, 0; 0, 0, m, 0; p, 0, 0, E_p in the last row.

However, I think there is a typo here as it should be:

Matrix Lambda with upper index mu and lower index nu equals a 4 by 4 matrix: top row E_p, 0, 0, -p; second row 0, m, 0, 0; third row 0, 0, m, 0; bottom row -p, 0, 0, E_p.


When this boost matrix is used and followed through the rest of the derivation everything is resolved - phew!

Once again thanks for your help with this it has helped me a lot as it got me to think about my calculations and, naively, I never considered typos.
 
Attachments
  • Equation p^μ = (E_p, 0, 0, p), a four-momentum with energy component E_p, zero transverse components and longitudinal component p.
    1705605180141.png
    1.7 KB · Views: 153
diffidus said:
I feel a bit like a bad penny now but I have looked over my calculation and I can now see where the minus signs come from.
The problem is given in terms of a boost in the z-direction:
View attachment 338787
From this we get:

View attachment 338788
Which can be calculated independently using:

View attachment 338789
Using this second method the minus signs in the A matrix arise since in the projection formula the momentum vectors are covariant and so should be:
View attachment 338790
So for example:

View attachment 338791
Similarly for A30.
The bad news is this still leaves me with the original problem! The good news, however, is that I think I have spotted the issue.

In the original problem equation 13.29 gives the boost matrix as (multiplied by 1/m):

View attachment 338794
However, I think there is a typo here as it should be:

View attachment 338795

When this boost matrix is used and followed through the rest of the derivation everything is resolved - phew!

Once again thanks for your help with this it has helped me a lot as it got me to think about my calculations and, naively, I never considered typos.
Thank you for clearing this point. I think now that there is no typo at all, and the resolution for the minus sign in the original problem is the same: the polarization vectors in 13.30 are contravariant, but they are covariant in 13.40. This gives us the minus signs in the answer, doesn't it?
 
billtodd said:
A photon doesnt have a mass. it's massless.
Yes. However,
Printed page from a textbook, section 13.2 Massive electromagnetism, with footnotes on the left and the Lagrangian for a massive vector field, equation (13.17), in the text.

(Lancaster, Blundell, Quantum Field Theory for the Gifted Amateur)
 
I remember this Lagrangian called proca lagrangian density. otherwise I cannot recall.