Problem understanding entropy (two different definitions?)

AI Thread Summary
Entropy has two main definitions: one related to randomness and the other to energy unavailable for work. Statistical entropy is broader in scope, while thermodynamic entropy applies specifically to systems near equilibrium. The Gibbs entropy formula demonstrates the equivalence of these two concepts under certain conditions, particularly within a canonical ensemble. For systems close to thermodynamic equilibrium, statistical entropy can be accurately approximated by thermodynamic entropy. Understanding this relationship is crucial for grasping the principles of thermodynamics and statistical mechanics.
James Brown
Messages
21
Reaction score
11
In the definition of entropy, there are two. One is about the degree of randomness and one is about energy that is not available to do work. What is the relationship between them?
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • Like
Likes Demystifier and vanhees71
James Brown said:
In the definition of entropy, there are two. One is about the degree of randomness and one is about energy that is not available to do work. What is the relationship between them?
The former is statistical entropy and the latter is thermodynamic entropy. Statistical entropy is more general, while thermodynamic entropy is only defined for systems close to thermodynamic equilibrium. It can be shown (see the box in the link in the post above) that statistical entropy for systems close to thermodynamic equilibrium can be well approximated by thermodynamic entropy.
 
Problem: You’re an Uber driver with a Tesla Model 3. Today’s low: 30F, high: 65F. You want to reach a USD$ profit target in the least number of hours, but your choices could have added cost. Do you preheat the battery only when you are headed to the charging station (to increase the charging rate by warming the battery — however the battery might not be “warm enough” when your reach the charger and thus slower charging rates), or do you always “navigate to the charger” the entire day (which...
Been around 40 years since I took basic physics in college and while I remember doing some examples of insulation values / energy conduction, I doubt I could to the math now even if I could find the formulas. I have some some corrugated plastic sheet (think of the plastic signs you see on the side of the road) that is used in bee hives. Also have some used in a green house though a bit different in dimensions than this example but the general approach should still apply. Typically, both...
Thread 'Is Callen right in claiming dQ=TdS for all quasi-static processes?'
Hello! I am currently reading the second edition of Callen's Thermodynamics and an Introduction to Thermostatistics, and I have a question regarding Callen's definition of quasi-static. On page 96, Callen says: Another way of characterizing Callen's definition is that a process is quasi-static if it traces out a continuous curve in the system's configuration space. So far it's all well and good. A little later, Callen claims that the identification of $$TdS$$ as the heat transfer is only...
Back
Top