Projectile motion problem (moving ships firing a projectile)

6 replies · 2K views · last reply
Istiak
Messages
158
Reaction score
12
Homework Statement
Two ships are traveling parallel to each other in opposite directions with speeds v_1 and v_2 One ship fires on the other. At what angle \phi (with respect to the direction of the firing ship) should the gun be aimed at the target ship in order to make a if the shot is fired at the instant when both vessels are on the straight line perpendicular to their course? The shell velocity v_0 is assumed constant.
Relevant Equations
v=u+at
Question :

Physics problem text in English and Bengali describing two ships moving in opposite directions at speeds v1 and v2, with one ship firing a shot at angle φ to the target ship's direction of motion.


Solution attempt :

Handwritten physics working on lined paper showing two ships on a horizontal line with a projectile launched at angle theta from one ship, a dashed parabolic trajectory, and equations relating ship speeds, separation d and the projectile's range R.

Handwritten derivation on lined paper: R = u - V2t, then Vx t = X - V2t, then Vx = X/t - V2, then V1 + V0 cos φ = X/t - V2, leading to V0 cos φ = X·(1/(2V0 sin φ)) - V2 - V1 and further rearrangement with 2V0 sin φ terms.

Handwritten derivation on lined paper: a chain of equations with partial derivatives of x with respect to time, ending in d(x)/dt^2 = sin(phi) tan(phi), with a calculator visible at the top.
 
Please do not post images of working. That is for diagrams and textbook extracts.
Type the algebra in, define the variables, and explain the basis of each starting equation.
 
How can we interpret the statement "if the shot is fired at the instant when both vessels are on the straight line perpendicular to their course". I interpret it as follows: The ships are in two parallel lines which have distance ##d## and the shot is fired when the distance between the ships equals ##d##. @haruspex what do you think about this?
 
Delta2 said:
How can we interpret the statement "if the shot is fired at the instant when both vessels are on the straight line perpendicular to their course". I interpret it as follows: The ships are in two parallel lines which have distance ##d## and the shot is fired when the distance between the ships equals ##d##. @haruspex what do you think about this?
Yes. The original would have been fine had it said:
"if the shot is fired at the instant when the vessels are on the same straight line perpendicular to their course"
 
haruspex said:
Yes. The original would have been fine had it said:
"if the shot is fired at the instant when the vessels are on the same straight line perpendicular to their course"

well, now that we agreed at the interpretation, I think that in order to solve this problem we need to determine two angles the angle of ##\vec{v_0}## with the z-axis (gravity axis) and the angle of ##\vec{v_0}## with one of the parallel lines.
Edit something tells me that the problem wants only the second angle, the first angle is considered to be 90 (or zero) that is shot parallel to horizontal plane.
 
Last edited:
Delta2 said:
well, now that we agreed at the interpretation, I think that in order to solve this problem we need to determine two angles the angle of ##\vec{v_0}## with the z-axis (gravity axis) and the angle of ##\vec{v_0}## with one of the parallel lines.
Edit something tells me that the problem wants only the second angle, the first angle is considered to be 90 (or zero) that is shot parallel to horizontal plane.
Since we are not given any distances, we can't consider the vertical motion. We can either suppose that is negligible or interpret the shell velocity as just its horizontal component. Indeed, those are the only ways for that velocity to be considered constant.
 
To @Istiakshovon : I think you have misunderstood the statement of the problem and your work is towards solving a different problem. The situation in this problem is like this picture shows
Diagram of two horizontal ship paths with ship 1 above moving right at v1 and ship 2 below moving left at v2, and a diagonal missile trajectory from ship 1 to ship 2 with an angle marked \theta at ship 1.

i misnamed the angle as \theta, that is the \phi angle of the problem statement actually.