I Proving a property when elements of a group commute

1,456
44
By commutative, we know that ##ab = ba## for all a,b in G. Thus, why do we need to prove separately that ##a^n b^m = b^ma^n##? Isn't it the case that ##a^n## and ##b^m## are in fact elements of the group? So shouldn't the fact that they commute automatically be implied?
 

blue_leaf77

Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2,629
784
Isn't it the case that anana^n and bmbmb^m are in fact elements of the group?
Yes but each of ##a^n## and ##b^m## might equal another element of the group and they need not commute if the group is non-Abelian.
 
1,456
44
Yes but each of ##a^n## and ##b^m## might equal another element of the group and they need not commute if the group is non-Abelian.
Oh, I see. I neglected to see that the group is not actually abelian
 

mathman

Science Advisor
7,612
368
The proof you want seems trivial.
 

WWGD

Science Advisor
Gold Member
4,137
1,726
By commutative, we know that ##ab = ba## for all a,b in G. Thus, why do we need to prove separately that ##a^n b^m = b^ma^n##? Isn't it the case that ##a^n## and ##b^m## are in fact elements of the group? So shouldn't the fact that they commute automatically be implied?
Why do you believe you need to prove it separately?
 

lavinia

Science Advisor
Gold Member
3,047
516
By commutative, we know that ##ab = ba## for all a,b in G. Thus, why do we need to prove separately that ##a^n b^m = b^ma^n##? Isn't it the case that ##a^n## and ##b^m## are in fact elements of the group? So shouldn't the fact that they commute automatically be implied?
If you know that the group is commutative then there is nothing to prove. ##a^nb^m = b^ma^n## by definition. If you do not know that the group is commutative then you need a proof.
 
Last edited:

mathman

Science Advisor
7,612
368
Proof: [tex]a^nb^m=a^{n-1}bab^{m-1}[/tex], etc.
 

Want to reply to this thread?

"Proving a property when elements of a group commute" You must log in or register to reply here.

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Hot Threads

Top