Question: atomic polarizability (Purcell book)

  • Level: Graduate 
  • Thread starter bobfei
  • Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Atomic Book
2 replies · 3K views · last reply
bobfei
Messages
29
Reaction score
0
Hi All,

I would like to ask a question on Purcell’s EM textbook on atomic polarizability.

Textbook page 362 showing a hydrogen atom in an external electric field E pointing up, with the negative cloud pulled down and the nucleus pushed up, and text with equations 24 and 25 (dz/a approximately E/(e/a^2), p = e dz approximately a^3 E).

On page 362, Purcell put the relation:

[tex]\underbrace {\frac{{\Delta z}}{a}}_{{\rm{dimensionless}}} \approx \underbrace {\frac{E}{{e/{a^2}}}}_{\frac{1}{{{\varepsilon _0}}}}[/tex]


I suspect that it has missed the constant [tex]{\varepsilon _0}[/tex] here. The left side of the approximate equation is a dimensionless quantity, whereas on the right side:

E has dimension [tex]\frac{e}{{{\varepsilon _0}{a^2}}}[/tex], dividing by the denominator, the net result will still have the dimension of [tex]\frac{1}{{{\varepsilon _0}}}[/tex].

But why Purcell put the equation like that? I also compared with Griffiths book as well as Wikipedia, both of which gave the correct dimension. So Purcell must be wrong here, but why he makes such a junior level mistake?

Textbook page excerpt on atomic polarizability: Figure 4.1 shows a sphere of radius a with +q nucleus at center and -q electron cloud; Figure 4.2 shows the nucleus displaced by d with E field; equation alpha = 4 pi epsilon0 a^3 = 3 epsilon0 v, with a red box around the epsilon0 term.



Thanks,
Bob
 
Attachments
  • Textbook page 362 showing a hydrogen atom distorted by an electric field E: a dark blurred electron cloud between charged plates, with negative charge pulled down and nucleus pushed up, plus equations 24 and 25 for Delta z over a approximately E over e/a squared and p = e Delta z approximately a cubed E.
    purcell_362.jpg
    62.7 KB · Views: 682
  • Textbook page excerpt, Chapter 4, page 162: text on atomic polarizability, with the equation alpha = 4 pi epsilon0 a^3 = 3 epsilon0 v, equation 4.2, and the final epsilon0 term boxed in red. Figures 4.1 and 4.2 above show a sphere with charges.
    g_162.png
    26.1 KB · Views: 1,331
Last edited: