Recommended mathematical courses for a Physics major

In summary, the conversation is about an undergraduate Physics student seeking advice on which optional mathematical courses to choose for their third year. They mention their previous courses and their own interest in abstract algebra. The three courses they are considering are Galois theory, algebraic geometry, and algebraic topology. The other person advises against Galois theory, suggests algebraic topology as the most useful for physics, and mentions the importance of numerical methods. The student agrees and mentions they are choosing the courses more for pleasure than for career usefulness. The other person expresses concern about this approach and suggests finding a balance between pleasure and career-oriented courses.
  • #1
torito_verdejo
20
4
Hi, you all,

I am an undegrad Physics student and I'm choosing my optional courses for my third year. I'm looking for advice (or opinions, if you prefer) since I'm not sure what of the following mathematical, optional courses would be more "beneficial" (I know this term is abstract) to my physics formation. Note that this course will already follow four semesters of real analysis, two of complex analysis, one on linear algebra, and another on functional analysis. Note too that I am eager to study abstract algebra on my own (as I already have) so I don't fear not "being ready" for the course.

What do you think I should choose among the following? (If you can, separate your answer in what to choose according to its "beauty", and what to choose according to its applicability to physics):

1. Galois theory
2. Algebraic geometry
3. Algebraic topology

All three are first courses on each subject. Thank you in advance.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Forget Galois theory. It's nice but more or less useless in physics. Algebraic geometry is as ambitious as algebraic topology is. However, algebraic geometry is ring theory, hence useless in physics (duck and run ...), and algebraic topology is closest to physics, e.g. in cosmology and differential geometry. You probably won't see the connections to physics, but they exist. We still do not know how our universe looks like, we have to integrate over a lot of paths in physics, and it is important to know whether e.g. there is a singularity in between. Algebraic topology provides the tools which are necessary to classify the manifolds which occur in physics.
 
  • Like
Likes torito_verdejo and mpresic3
  • #3
Have you had a good course in numerical methods yet?
 
  • Like
Likes mpresic3
  • #4
torito_verdejo said:
Hi, you all,

I am an undegrad Physics student and I'm choosing my optional courses for my third year. I'm looking for advice (or opinions, if you prefer) since I'm not sure what of the following mathematical, optional courses would be more "beneficial" (I know this term is abstract) to my physics formation. Note that this course will already follow four semesters of real analysis, two of complex analysis, one on linear algebra, and another on functional analysis. Note too that I am eager to study abstract algebra on my own (as I already have) so I don't fear not "being ready" for the course.

What do you think I should choose among the following? (If you can, separate your answer in what to choose according to its "beauty", and what to choose according to its applicability to physics):

1. Galois theory
2. Algebraic geometry
3. Algebraic topology

All three are first courses on each subject. Thank you in advance.
Are you sure you shouldn't be a math major? :wink:
 
  • Like
Likes torito_verdejo and fresh_42
  • #5
Dr. Courtney said:
Have you had a good course in numerical methods yet?
Actually I didn't and, now that I think of it, it would certainly be extremely useful. I'll think of it further, as there is also a course in numerical analysis at my disposal. Nevertheless I must confess that this mathematical courses I'll be taking are choosen more for pleasure than for usefullness, and I miss abstract algebra. This said, I really appreciate your idea and I will consider it.
 
  • #6
fresh_42 said:
Forget Galois theory. It's nice but more or less useless in physics. Algebraic geometry is as ambitious as algebraic topology is. However, algebraic geometry is ring theory, hence useless in physics (duck and run ...), and algebraic topology is closest to physics, e.g. in cosmology and differential geometry. You probably won't see the connections to physics, but they exist. We still do not know how our universe looks like, we have to integrate over a lot of paths in physics, and it is important to know whether e.g. there is a singularity in between. Algebraic topology provides the tools which are necessary to classify the manifolds which occur in physics.
Thanks for the detailed answer, it really helped me. I guess I'll leave Galois theory as a summer reading. Concerning algebraic geometry, I thought it would be applicable to theoretical physics simply and naively because it's something I can't stop hearing about (and it sounds sexy, hahaha). I trust you though, on your telling me algebraic topology will be more nourishing for my physics. Actually this semester we are being mortified with hamiltonian formalism by the hand of Arnold and when I saw "symplectic manifold" on the syllabus of alg. topology I suffered from a PTSD episode. Hahaha. I'm kidding, I like the formalism, but it is very sudden for a second year undergrad.
 
  • #7
torito_verdejo said:
Nevertheless I must confess that this mathematical courses I'll be taking are choosen more for pleasure than for usefullness
Doesn't that seem a bit misplaced? I guess it's best if you can have both (pleasure and career-oriented), but putting pleasure before career pursuit seems misplaced to me.
 
  • Like
Likes torito_verdejo
  • #8
torito_verdejo said:
Nevertheless I must confess that this mathematical courses I'll be taking are choosen more for pleasure than for usefullness, and I miss abstract algebra.
This sounds as if Galois theory is on the list again. It is not too difficult, closed in itself and really beautiful. At the end you cannot use it anywhere, but you can answer the three ancient classical problems: squaring a circle, doubling a cube, and trisection an angle. They are all impossible, but Galois theory can tell you why. However, the old Greeks are not very attractive these days.

I would still choose algebraic topology. It has the amount of abstract algebra you are thinking of, but on its way will tell you useful things about boundary operators (aka derivatives) and that cohomology theory can actually be useful. E.g. here's what I found on algebraic topology on Wikipedia (translated via Google)
In physics, too, the Chern classes have been increasingly used since around 2015 and are also explicitly called this (which was not the case before), since now, not only in high-energy physics, but also increasingly in solid-state physics, new differential topological aspects are dealt with: In addition to older Umlauf "statements in physics, such as the Aharonov-Bohm effect of quantum mechanics or the well-known Meissner-Ochsenfeld effect of superconductivity, are used by Chern classes in physics primarily for the differential topological classification of Umlauf singularities, especially in the so-called quantum Hall-Effect or with the so-called topological superconductors or topological insulators.
 
  • Like
Likes torito_verdejo
  • #9
torito_verdejo said:
Concerning algebraic geometry, I thought it would be applicable to theoretical physics simply and naively because it's something I can't stop hearing about (and it sounds sexy, hahaha).
Algebraic geometry sounds geometrical, but not in the sense of real numbers. It deals with ideals of polynomial rings. It is the zeros of those polynomials which provide the geometric part. Does this sound interesting:
A Gröbner basis is a finite generating system for an ideal ##I## in the polynomial ring ##K [X_{1}, \ldots, X_{n }]## over the field ##K##, which is particularly suitable for deciding whether a given polynomial belongs to the ideal or not.
 
  • Like
Likes torito_verdejo
  • #10
Of the three courses you list, AlgebraicTopology is most relevant to physics, assuming you go in for general relativity, field theory, or maybe high-energy theory. A numerical analysis course would be most useful if you intend to intern at a laboratory during summers. This is likely not the last time you can take algebraic topology, galois theory, or algebraic topology. You may get a chance in graduate school. If you have a research advisor, (s)he is probably a good source to ask
 
  • Like
Likes torito_verdejo

FAQ: Recommended mathematical courses for a Physics major

1. What are the necessary math courses for a Physics major?

The recommended math courses for a Physics major typically include Calculus I, II, and III, Linear Algebra, and Differential Equations. These courses provide a strong foundation in mathematical concepts and techniques that are essential for understanding and solving problems in physics.

2. Do I need to take all of these math courses?

While it is highly recommended to take all of the recommended math courses for a Physics major, some universities may have slightly different requirements. It is important to check with your specific university to determine the exact math courses needed for your degree.

3. Can I substitute any of these math courses with other courses?

In some cases, universities may allow students to substitute certain math courses with other courses, such as Advanced Calculus or Multivariable Calculus. However, it is important to consult with your academic advisor before making any substitutions to ensure that you are still meeting the necessary requirements for your degree.

4. What if I struggle with math?

If you struggle with math, it is important to seek help from a tutor or your professor. Many universities offer tutoring services for math courses, and your professor may also have office hours where you can ask for additional help. It is important to address any difficulties with math early on, as it is a crucial component of a Physics major.

5. Are there any other math courses that would be beneficial for a Physics major?

In addition to the recommended math courses, it may also be beneficial for a Physics major to take courses in Statistics, Complex Analysis, and Numerical Methods. These courses can provide additional mathematical tools and techniques that can be useful in solving complex physics problems.

Similar threads

Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
974
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Back
Top