Relative Velocity Problem: Finding Train Speed from Raindrop Angle

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
2 replies · 9K views
Mr Davis 97
Messages
1,461
Reaction score
44

Homework Statement


A person looking out the window of a stationary train notices that rain drops are falling vertically down at a speed of 5.0 m/s relative to the ground. When the train moves at a constant velocity, the raindrops make an angle of 25° when they move past the window. How fast is the train moving?

Homework Equations


##\vec{v_{AC}} = \vec{v_{AB}} + \vec{v_{BC}}##

The Attempt at a Solution


T = train, R = rain, G = ground
##\vec{v_{TG}} = \vec{v_{TR}} + \vec{v_{RG}}##
##\vec{v_{TG}} = \vec{v_{RG}} - \vec{v_{RT}}##
##v_x = 0~m/s-[(5~m/s)\sin25^{\circ}] = 2.1131~m/s##
##v_y = (-5~m/s) -[(5~m/s)\cos25^{\circ}] = -0.468~m/s##
##\vec{v_{TG}} = \sqrt{(2.1131~m/s)^2 + (-0.468~m/s)^2} = 2.16~m/s##

However, according to the solution manual, the correct answer is 2.3 m/s. Where am I going wrong?
 
on Phys.org
Try drawing a right triangle.

The vertical length is the trains speed.
The horizontal length is the rain drop speed of 5.0.

Which angle are you looking from?
What trig will help you solve it in one quick calculation?
 
RJLiberator said:
Try drawing a right triangle.

The vertical length is the trains speed.
The horizontal length is the rain drop speed of 5.0.

Which angle are you looking from?
What trig will help you solve it in one quick calculation?
What do you mean "the vertical length is the train's speed"? Do you mean horizontal?