Research topics in Statistical Physics

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around potential research topics in Statistical Physics for an undergraduate project. Participants explore various areas of interest, including connections to quantum mechanics and cosmology, while seeking to identify specific topics that diverge from traditional subjects like the Ising model.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses a desire to explore Statistical Physics, particularly in deriving macroscopic results from microscopic behavior, and seeks suggestions for research topics beyond magnetism.
  • Another participant suggests investigating quantum phase transitions as a possible research avenue.
  • A participant mentions the importance of discussing research topics with a faculty member and emphasizes the need to align with their interests.
  • It is noted that the faculty member has allowed the participant to choose a topic within equilibrium statistical physics, without providing specific suggestions.
  • The participant has considered topics related to cosmology and quantum mechanics, referencing articles on black holes and cosmological phase transitions.
  • There is a discussion about the relevance of advanced theories like General Relativity (GR) and Quantum Field Theory (QFT) in relation to the suggested topics.
  • Some participants highlight the potential for statistical mechanics to describe systems like stars and galaxies, though specific references are not provided.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree on the need to identify specific research topics within Statistical Physics, but multiple competing views on potential areas of focus remain. The discussion does not reach a consensus on which topics are most suitable.

Contextual Notes

Participants express uncertainty regarding the prerequisites for understanding the suggested topics, particularly the need for GR and QFT knowledge. There are also limitations in the specificity of the research topics discussed.

leo.
Messages
90
Reaction score
4
Currently I'm in the last year of the Physics course and I've been thinking about working in a project of undergraduate research, specifically in Statistical Physics. Two years ago I've already done a project like that in Fluid Mechanics combined with Gauge Theories and in that project I've studied the geometry of locomotion of deformable bodies at low Reynolds number. It was more of a mathematical physics project.

Now since I'm almost finishing the undergraduate program I've already taken courses on electrodynamics, quantum mechanics, thermodynamics, mathematical physics and statistical physics.

I've thought on doing this new undergraduate research on Statistical Physics because I like the idea of deriving results about macroscopic systems by looking at the microscopic scale. Since I've taken most of the important courses I want to leverage that now.

My only problem is that I've no idea about what are possible research topics in Statistical Physics. I've searched a little on the internet and the major topics I've found are related to magnetism, like the Ising model. I'm sure, however, that there are many other possible research topics. I really want to find one such research topic where it is possible to leverage things like quantum mechanics and electrodynamics.

So, what are possible research topics in Statistical Physics, other than those related to magnetism like the Ising model? What topics bridge with quantum mechanics and with electrodynamics? I have a good mathematical background also anyway.

Two possibilities which I thought about were:
  1. Something related to cosmology. I don't really know if there's anything that can be done with Statistical Physics and cosmology together, but it seems to be nice if there was something in this category.
  2. Something related to the study of molecules which applying statistical physics to analyze how things work microscopically we can end up with results of interest for chemistry and biology. I also have just this rough idea, so I don't know a precise research topic that could use this.
Are there any nice research possibilities in any of these two categories? And what about something else?

Thanks very much in advance!
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
I would look into quantum phase transitions possibly (although of course you should eventually choose a specific system to focus on).
 
leo. said:
Currently I'm in the last year of the Physics course and I've been thinking about working in a project of undergraduate research, specifically in Statistical Physics. Two years ago I've already done a project like that in Fluid Mechanics combined with Gauge Theories and in that project I've studied the geometry of locomotion of deformable bodies at low Reynolds number. It was more of a mathematical physics project.

Now since I'm almost finishing the undergraduate program I've already taken courses on electrodynamics, quantum mechanics, thermodynamics, mathematical physics and statistical physics.

I've thought on doing this new undergraduate research on Statistical Physics because I like the idea of deriving results about macroscopic systems by looking at the microscopic scale. Since I've taken most of the important courses I want to leverage that now.

My only problem is that I've no idea about what are possible research topics in Statistical Physics. I've searched a little on the internet and the major topics I've found are related to magnetism, like the Ising model. I'm sure, however, that there are many other possible research topics. I really want to find one such research topic where it is possible to leverage things like quantum mechanics and electrodynamics.

So, what are possible research topics in Statistical Physics, other than those related to magnetism like the Ising model? What topics bridge with quantum mechanics and with electrodynamics? I have a good mathematical background also anyway.

Two possibilities which I thought about were:
  1. Something related to cosmology. I don't really know if there's anything that can be done with Statistical Physics and cosmology together, but it seems to be nice if there was something in this category.
  2. Something related to the study of molecules which applying statistical physics to analyze how things work microscopically we can end up with results of interest for chemistry and biology. I also have just this rough idea, so I don't know a precise research topic that could use this.
Are there any nice research possibilities in any of these two categories? And what about something else?

Thanks very much in advance!

Back up a bit.

If you intend to do this as a formal undergraduate research project, shouldn't you be discussing this first with the faculty member that you wish to work with and who will be supervising your work? There is no point in any of us coming up with topics and suggestions, and then that faculty member does not want you to work on that area.

Zz.
 
So is this an actual research project with a faculty member? In that case you should be trying to determine their interests to find someone who can advise you.
 
Indeed it is an actual research project with a faculty member. In truth I've considered working with a physicist and I did talk to him. He just said that being a topic in statistical physics it is fine, so he just suggested me to take a look on what I want to work with within statistical physics without a more specific suggestion of a topic. He just told me to pick something in equilibrium statistical physics.

Because of that I've started searching for what can be done in that area. The most common topics are related to the Ising model. I wanted to do something different though. I thought on something involving cosmology and/or quantum mechanics but I'm still unsure. I've been looking for quantum phase transitions as suggested and found some interesting articles like "Black Holes as Critical Point of Quantum Phase Transition" and "Cosmological Phase Transitions". I've been thinking on something along that lines.

More than that I've found out recently that systems like stars and galaxies can be described within the framework of statistical mechanics. I just don't know of any specific reference on that.

Are there topics which I could look at on those lines?
 
Last edited:
So is this faculty member asking for you to come up with your own original research project or just to find a more specific topic?

Based on the first paper you posted, I assume you have heard of AdS/CFT in condensed matter (people also just refer to it as holography). If not then I can explain a bit about it. However, I really think it would be necessary to have taken classes in GR, QFT and advanced quantum matter. It definitely takes a very unconventional approach to condensed matter problems, but what is very profound is thermodynamics and also hydro (on long length and time scales) falls very naturally out of the theory.

Some of the interesting topics people are looking at nowadays which you might like are the application to quantum chaos and entanglement.
 
The faculty member has told me to pick a more specific topic, with the only constraint that it were in equilibrium statistical physics. I believe the details of the research project itself will be discussed after that. So for now I'm looking for the topic.

Now, although I haven't taken classes on GR I have a good background on differential geometry on manifolds which I believe could make one preliminary study of GR to be feasible since in the past I've had (although informally) studied a little about GR. Now QFT I've really never studied. In that point I ask: considering each paper I've linked (regarding black holes and cosmological phase transitions), what each of them requires? Both requires GR and QFT or some of them requires just one of those theories? Because it is quite common here to have undergraduate research projects where some of the time is dedicated to the study of a required theory which the student hadn't learned before, so I think at first perhaps those topics could still be considered.

On the other hand, what about the description of stars and galaxies? Sorry if I'm saying this in a quite "loose" manner, it's just that some years ago I've read a little about it and I don't really remember what could be studied regarding systems like that, but I believe that statistical physics could play a role here.

Now, quantum chaos is something I really wouldn't get into. In the mechanics course I've taken chaotic classical dynamical systems weren't considered, so I've never ever studied them. I believe getting into the quantum version without any notion whatsoever about the classical one wouldn't be a good idea.

I've searched about quantum phase transitions and found that interesting papers about the "cosmological phase transitions". I'm just unsure if I could tackle it, since I would need to first study QFT right? Anyway, thanks very much for the suggestions up to know!
 
Last edited:
The first paper I think is explicitly referring to AdS and also is making a lot of reference to the strong coupling large N limit (this is the regime where the gravity side become classical). The large N limit is something you use for an expansion in field theory. You say you have N flavors of fields (N would refer to colors in QCD) and then you calculate the path integral rescaling the fields and doing a saddle point approximation. This would be a sort of semiclassical limit where quantum corrections are 1/N etc. However, it makes a significant difference whether you have vectors or matrices. For the vector large N limit everything decouples via the central limit theorem, but for matrices you still have a strongly coupled theory after you do this. The original paper is by t'Hooft I think and the matrix large N limit is behind Maldacena's conjecture.

I am not very familiar with cosmology by any means but what I can tell from skimming the second paper is that based on what I know about the techniques used (Euclidean field theory, the effective action, Langrangian formalism in general relativity), this would require a pretty extensive knowledge of field theory.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
1K