Engineering Resolve Parallel Resistor Error: I Set Rtot = 0.168

AI Thread Summary
The user set the total resistance (Rtot) to 0.168 and calculated R1 incorrectly, leading to confusion about the results. The correct approach involves understanding that the slope of the I versus V graph represents conductance, not resistance. The calculations should maintain consistent units, as 0.168 should be expressed as conductance (Ω^−1) rather than resistance (Ω). Additionally, the user misapplied the formula for parallel resistors, leading to incorrect results. Emphasizing unit consistency is crucial for solving similar problems accurately.
amwil
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
Two resistors, R1 and R2, are connected in parallel to a power supply that has voltage V and negligible internal resistance. R2 = 9.00 Ω and the resistance of R1 is not known. For several values of V, you measure the current I flowing through the voltage source. You plot the data as I versus V and find that they lie close to a straight line that has slope 0.168 Ω^−1.
Relevant Equations
V = IR
1/Rtot = 1/R1 +1/R2
Since the slope of the I versus V graph is equal to 1/R, I set Rtot equal to 0.168. So then I subtracted 1/0.168 by 1/9 and got 1/R1 =5.841. I then found R1 equal to 1/5.841 or 0.171 but it said I was wrong. Can someone tell me what I did wrong?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
amwil said:
1/Rtot = 1/R1 +1/R2
Can someone tell me what I did wrong?
0.168 Ω^−1. is a conductance = I / V.
V / I = 1 / 0.168 = 5.952 Ω

1 / ( 1 / 5.952 - 1 / 9 ) = 17.575 Ω
1 / ( 0.168 - 1 / 9 ) = 17.578 Ω
 
Try again, but everytime you write down a number include it's units. As @Baluncore said it's not 0.168, it's 0.168⋅(1/Ω) = 0.168⋅(A/V). This practice will help in future problems too.

So, in your solution you suggest 1/(9V/A) - 1/(0.168A/V), this doesn't make sense because the units don't match.
 
  • Like
Likes sophiecentaur and topsquark
Back
Top