Engineering Review of Concepts: Air Recycling Systems (closed-loop/open-loop)

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on classifying elements of air recycling systems into closed-loop/open-loop categories and CO2 removal/oxygen supply functions. Initial classifications included errors, particularly with water electrolysis and the spelling of "amine." Participants clarified that cryogenic tanks and chlorate candles are open-loop oxygen supplies, while water electrolysis can be either but is typically open-loop. For CO2 removal, lithium hydroxide is categorized as open-loop, while metal oxide and rapid amine systems are closed-loop. The final arrangement provided correct classifications for each element.
Jonathan F
Messages
2
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
Review of Concepts: Air Recycling Systems
Classify each of the following methods according to whether it is used to supply oxygen or remove CO 2 , and whether it is most closely associated with an open-loop or closed-loop process.
Relevant Equations
1. Chlorate Candles
2. Metal Oxide Absorbers
3. Rapid Cycling Anime System
4. Water Electrolysis
5. Cryogenic Storage Tanks
6. Lithium Hydroxide Granules
Hey, first post here.
So I have to classify these 6 elements under closed-loop/open-loop system and under CO2 removal/oxygen supply.
I thought it should be:
Closed-loop CO2 removal: Rapid cycling anime, Lithium granules
Closed-loop oxygen supply: Water electrolysis, Cryogenic tanks
Open-loop CO2 removal: Metal oxide absorber
Open-loop oxygen supply: Chlorate candles

But I was wrong. Can someone please help me figure out how it is supposed to be arranged?
Thank you
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Jonathan F said:
I thought it should be:
Closed-loop CO2 removal: Rapid cycling anime, Lithium granules
Closed-loop oxygen supply: Water electrolysis, Cryogenic tanks
Open-loop CO2 removal: Metal oxide absorber
Open-loop oxygen supply: Chlorate candles

But I was wrong. Can someone please help me figure out how it is supposed to be arranged?
Thank you
Cryogenic tanks are definitely "open loop oxygen supply" category. Water electrolysis may be open or close loop depending on circumstances, but typically is open loop. Also, "amine", not "anime".
 
trurle said:
Cryogenic tanks are definitely "open loop oxygen supply" category. Water electrolysis may be open or close loop depending on circumstances, but typically is open loop. Also, "amine", not "anime".
Thx, I guess anime was an instinct.
The solution was:
Oxygen supply -
cryogenic (open)
chlorate candles (open)
water electrolysis (closed)

co2 removal -
lithium hydroxide (open)
metal oxide (closed)
rapid amine (closed)
 
  • Like
Likes trurle
Back
Top