# River crossing and relative velocities

Hi everyone,

I've been having difficulties with this problem for a while. Here is my best attempt at solving it. If there's anything wrong, I honestly can't figure it out :). I would appreciate if anyone could go over it quickly and tell me if/what I did wrong.

## Homework Statement

A boat crosses a wide river with a speed of 12km/h relative to water. The river has a uniform speed of 6 km/h due east relative to earth.
(a) Determine the speed of the boat relative to a stationary observer.
(b) In what direction should the boat be heading to reach an opposite point directly across the river?

## Homework Equations

I've set up the velocities as such:
Vbe = Velocity of the boat relative to the earth (and observer),
Vbw = Velocity of the boat relative to the water, and
Vwe = Velocity of the water relative to the earth.

Therefore, Vbe = Vbw + Vwe

## The Attempt at a Solution

After drawing a picture of the situation, I've determined that

Vbw = (-12sinΘ i + 12cosΘ j) km/h
Vwe = (6i + 0j) km/h
Vbe = (0i + Vbe j) km/h ← This is something I'm not certain of. Am I right to assure that since we want to go directly across the river, relative to the earth, this vector should have a 0 i-component?

Using Vbe = Vbw + Vwe,

1) -12sinΘ + 6 = 0
→ Θ = 30° (counterclockwise from positive y-axis)

2) magnitude of Vbe = 12cosΘ = 12cos30 = 10.39

To answer a) using the above, Vbe = (0i + 10.39j) km/h, or 10.39 km/h due north relative to the observer.
b) Direction should be 120° from positive x-axis.

Have I made any mistakes somewhere? For some reason, I had quite a hard time visualizing this problem.

Egoyan

Related Introductory Physics Homework Help News on Phys.org
haruspex
Homework Helper
Gold Member
Your answer and reasoning look right for b). Part a) is unclear - you cannot answer it without assuming a relative angle.

Hi,

Thanks for taking the time to look at the problem.

That's what I thought too - and that's part of why I had such a hard time visualizing it, I believe. But this was an exam question (I am 100% certain of the phrasing, I've got a copy of it with me), and I was wondering what was the deal here...

Some of my classmates were illustrating the problem as a triangle, setting it up such that the hypotenuse would be the resultant velocity relative to the observer; that is v=√(12^2+6^2) = 13.4 km/h. Anyone knows if this could be right?

Thanks again,

Egoyan

haruspex
Homework Helper
Gold Member
Hi,

Thanks for taking the time to look at the problem.

That's what I thought too - and that's part of why I had such a hard time visualizing it, I believe. But this was an exam question (I am 100% certain of the phrasing, I've got a copy of it with me), and I was wondering what was the deal here...

Some of my classmates were illustrating the problem as a triangle, setting it up such that the hypotenuse would be the resultant velocity relative to the observer; that is v=√(12^2+6^2) = 13.4 km/h. Anyone knows if this could be right?

Thanks again,

Egoyan
Yes, I suspect part a should have said "if the boat heads straight across relative to the water". This would make 13.4 correct.

Ah, yes, I see. Thanks a lot!