News Should scientific research be solely funded by the private sector?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SixNein
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Grants
AI Thread Summary
Tea Party members expressed frustration over Pell Grant funding, perceiving it as a form of welfare. Some participants in the discussion argued that Pell Grants are a valuable investment in education that can yield future returns, while others criticized the program for high dropout rates and perceived misuse of funds by students. Concerns were raised about the lack of merit-based criteria for grant eligibility, with suggestions that stricter requirements, such as maintaining a certain GPA, could improve accountability and reduce abuse. The debate highlighted the tension between supporting education for low-income students and concerns about fiscal responsibility, with some advocating for a reevaluation of government involvement in financing higher education. The conversation also touched on the broader implications of financial aid on college affordability and the potential for abuse within the system, suggesting a need for reform to ensure that aid effectively supports students who are genuinely committed to their education.
  • #101
SixNein said:
Why don't we end all government welfare for physicists, engineers, biologists, chemist, and other scientific disciplines? We could save plenty of money by shutting down NASA, NOAA, cutting the NSF, and other government facilities.

Why not let the private market fund all research?

I agree,... excepting two specifics. Scientific research for the DOD, i.e. research into weapons and other militarily relevant technology (such as GPS) and scientific research important for policy decisions, e.g. sociology, economics, and such...
are justified as supporting the primary role of government.

But by all means, defund NASA and NSF (and NEA and Public Media and ...). NOAA has important policy supporting research as well as data gathering important for Emergency Management so I'd say keep it funded. Move the rest to the private sector.

But everything in order of priority. Defund first social engineering programs and wealth redistribution which aside from the waste of tax dollars are actively detrimental to our society and economy. Then begin cutting productive programs which can be transitioned to the private sector and are not essential for defense, law enforcement, emergency management, and foreign relations.
 
Back
Top