Sick nonholonomic problem

  • Thread starter wrobel
  • Start date
3 replies · 2K views · last reply
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Messages
1,425
Reaction score
1,176
Consider a hoop of mass ##m## that is situated on a horizontal plane and rolls forward without slipping. The radius of the hoop, if I may be so bold, is a given function of time ##r=r(t)##. These are the ideal constraints.
Let ##x,y## be the coordinates of the hoop's center ##S## and let ##\psi## be its angle of rotation. I can give a formal definition of what this is if needed. The constraints are ##y=r,\quad \dot x=r\dot\psi##.
The kinetic energy is
$$T=\frac{m}{2}\Big(\dot x^2+\dot r^2\Big)+\frac{m}{2}\Big((r\dot\psi)^2+\dot r^2\Big).$$
Taking ##x,\psi## for generalized coordinates, we have
$$L=\frac{m}{2}\dot x^2+\frac{m}{2}(r\dot\psi)^2,\quad [L]_x\delta x+[L]_\psi\delta\psi=0,$$
where ##\delta x=r\delta\psi.##

my answer is
$$\dot\psi(t)=\frac{C}{r^{3/2}(t)}.$$





Hand-drawn diagram of a hoop with centre S on an x-y coordinate plane, touching the x-axis at its lowest point; a radius from S is labelled r(t), and a vertical line drops from S to the x-axis.
 
Last edited:
Gemini can't solve this problem. It writes all the formulas correctly except for the final step, when it substitutes the equation of constraint into the Lagrangian and gets the incorrect equations. That is a classic pitfall in nonholonomic systems.