Simple Mechanics Problem -- Block connected to a wall by a rope

5 replies · 2K views · last reply
domingoleung
Messages
7
Reaction score
1
Homework Statement
Block A (5 kg) is connected to the wall with a cord of tension T, and initially at rest on top of block B (10 kg) on a rough floor. If there is an applied force 54 N acting on block B, block B could move to the right while block A is still at rest due to the connecting cord. Assume the coefficient of kinetic friction between blocks A and B and between block B and the ground is μk = 0.3.

(i) Draw free body diagrams of blocks A and B.
(ii) Find the tension T of the cord and the acceleration of block B.
Relevant Equations
F = ma
Diagram of block A resting on block B on a horizontal floor, with a rope T from a vertical wall to A at 30 degrees above horizontal, and a 54N force pulling B to the right.
(So this is the system given)

The following is my analysis:
(i)
Two handwritten free-body diagrams. Left: block A with tension T at 30 degrees, components T sin 30 and T cos 30, normal force F_N1 up, friction f_K1 right, and weight 5g down. Right: block B with friction f_K1 left, F_N1 down, applied force F_app right, normal force F_N2 up, friction f_K2 left, and weight 10g down, with x and y axes shown.

(ii)
Handwritten working for a two-block pulley problem: Block A stationary, equations T sin 30 + F_N1 = 5g and T cos 30 = f_K1, substitution giving T = 14.5 N, then block B normal force and horizontal motion equation 54 - f_K1 - f_K2 = 10a yielding a = -0.515 m/s^2.

Well, my problem is - I got a negative acceleration and its quite impossible to have block B moving to the left. So I am wondering if there are any mistakes I've made.
 
Can you write out the equations for all the forces on both blocks? Horizontal and vertical. In particular, can you check the calculation of ##T##. How did you get that?
 
PeroK said:
Can you write out the equations for all the forces on both blocks? Horizontal and vertical. In particular, can you check the calculation of ##T##. How did you get that?

Okay, ##T## is correct.

I think I agree with you. You need a force of slightly more than ##54N## to get this system moving.

Increasing ##g## to ##10 m/s^2## makes things worse, of course.

You can check once more, but unless we've made the same mistake, I think the problem might be wrong. It's a bit suspicious, as ##54N## is approximately the force needed.
 
Last edited:
Equation 2 is incorrect. ##f_{k1}=\mu_k F_{N1}## and ##F_{N1}## is given by equation 1.
 
kuruman said:
##f_{k1}=\mu_k F_{N1}## and ##F_{N1}## is given by equation 1.

That's true, but considering horizontal forces on block ##A## also gives:

##f_{k1} = T\cos \theta##
 
Ah yes. I forgot A is not accelerating. I agree that the 54 N force is not enough to provide an acceleration to the right. A negative acceleration could be compatible with the situation in which block B is already moving and then block A is dropped on it to slow it down, but that's not what the problem says.
 
Last edited: